Posted by:
liquidleaf
at Sat Jun 17 09:22:10 2006 [ Email Message ] [ Show All Posts by liquidleaf ]
Here's what I've found on various sites, not just for "animal" euthanasia, which includes mammals and can be very different...
Freezing isn't really humane for reptiles. Because reptiles are coldblooded, they can survive (and thus be conscious) much lower temperatures than mammals. Ice crystals forming in the tissues would be very painful. Reptiles aren't mammals, and probably don't have the sensation of wanting to fall asleep before succumbing to hypothermia - mammals can die of hypothermia if their body temperatures drop a measly few degrees. Reptiles get slower and slower the colder they get, but that doesn't necessarily mean they aren't awake at all at the point where ice crystals start to form. Because of that possibility of consciousness.... erg, I wouldn't want to feel my muscles turning to ice, or subject an animal to that possibility.
Beheading isn't really humane either - others have mentioned noticing decapitated reptile heads moving around for a while after decapitation - again because of the slower metabolism, the reptile brain can survive longer without oxygen than mammals. So a beheaded snake could probably feel quite a bit of pain for a few minutes after the decapitation. Because of the (disgusting) massive "rattler roundups" where many snakes are decapitated, unfortunately there have been MANY observations of snakes appearing to look around and move their heads many minutes after decapitation.
CO2 euthanasia, once more because of reptiles' slow metabolisms, could be considered ineffective and somewhat inhumane as well. Again, reptiles can survive longer on less amounts of oxygen than mammals, so while CO2 euthanasia is humane for rats, a snake would take much longer to "suffocate", and would probably be conscious during suffocation since it's a much more drawn out process in reptiles.
The only method I found while researching the subject that was considered "instantaneous" and therefore humane (OTHER THAN VETERINARY CHEMICAL EUTHANASIA) would be immediate destruction of the brain. It seems to be the most gruesome, but reptiles are very hardy. Destruction of the brain tissue by crushing the head in a very abrupt manner or (read this on another site) quicky inserting a metal object into the brain case to destroy the brain tissue would be the swiftest, most effective, least traumatic means of euthanasia after injected chemical euthanasia, leaving the least amount of possibility of the snake being conscious during it's demise.
However, people will do what they feel most comfortable doing. The decision isn't an easy one, and ethically, subjecting an animal to a few moments of possible discomfort (using any of the above methods) might spare a lifetime of debilitating pain in the case of a severe deformaty.
[ Hide Replies ]
|
I've read quite a bit about reptile euth - liquidleaf, Sat Jun 17 09:22:10 2006
