Todd,
We obviously disagree on a few points and agree on others- as for me, I certainly don't take offense just because of a difference of opinion, provided these differences are expressed, as you have done, in a mature manner.
I did want to clarify a few things- I NEVER intentionally endorsed the idea of feeding outside of an enclosure- I'm not in favor of feeding outside of the normal enclosure at all, but what I mentioned as a "judgement call" was having a second enclosure where the snake was fed- when I kept numerous giants, I built a small facility that included shift cages. The retics and Burms were fed in the shift cages, which could be blocked off from the main enclosure by closing a door. Therefore, when the snake was eating , the enclosure could be cleaned without stressing him out or endangering volunteer help. A smaller version of this is sometimes used by our more...timid...herper friends to make feeding time safer. I see no need for it with smaller snakes, but neither do I see harm in it- other than, as I mentioned, the change of environment causing feeding problems in younger or WC snakes.
The major point where you and I diverge, however, is of course the feeding of live vs prekilled prey. Hot topic these days!
I don't feed live to my burms because I'm shallow and I want to watch- I do so because I'm not interested in creating domesticated snakes. They are predators, and I firmly believe they enjoy the hunt. I also work with raptors- Eagles, Hawks, Falcons, Owls- which are also predators, of course. Watch a hawk or a burm hunting, and you see an animal in it's element, doing what it was created to do. The sight of a big healthy burm gently taking a thawed mouse from a set of forceps sickens me at least as much as my supposed irresponsibility bothers you.
There are snakes I don't like feeding live- Balls, for instance, are terrible hunters, missing more often than they hit. Frozen works well for them, I admit. Any snake that is ill, cold, etc, should receive prekilled. They should also be fed a properly sized prey animal...too large or too small can be dangerous for them. Live prey should never be left in an enclosure uneaten, even for a few minutes, IMHO. But to say that a snake doing what a snake was meant to do is based on shallow values or irresponsibility...I'm afraid I can't agree with that concept. I've kept herps, particularly Burms, Retics, and Monitors, for nearly 30 years now, I've run a rescue facility, been a reptile consultant for two major zoos, and owned a commercial breeding business. Although a degree in herpetology was not available when I was in college, I did specialize in herpetology. I have never, since obtaining my first Burm in 1978, had a serious injury occur to any of my reptiles due to feeding live prey...and very few minor injuries, none of consequence. I do respect your opinion- as I stated in my earlier post, it's a judgement call, and must be based on your experience, the type of snake you own, his condition, etc.
I enjoyed your thoughtful- and thought provoking- post!
Cheers!
JJ