It is a shame that these two individuals manage to drag down every rational comment that is said which has anything negative to say about the US.
From all that I've read so far, I've seen very little rational behind all the negativity toward the US. Someone spends a few years here, in a single city, in what is probably the more downtrodden areas of that city...and assumes the entire country is like that. Not very rational. People love to criticize the US because it is the "in" thing to do. And they will never have a lack of ammunition, because there simply isn't ANY perfect country, government, or person. I'm sure if we wanted to expend the energy, we could find some equally heinous faults of England, Ireland, Germany, France...or whatever...and beat you over the head with them too.
There are some people here (Paul for example) who give rational arguments, and intelligent debate. That at least is a sign that these two are not representative of every US citizen!
They're ALL representative of our country. We have all types here. Those who argue with insults, and those who argue with gentle words. Those who support the reasons for the war, and those who do not. It's astonishing to me that anyone would assume an entire country is "like" the few people they argue with on a website. If I thought that way, I'd think all Englishmen were (insert male body part of choice here.) But I know that's not at all true.
America could indeed be considered a great country, but then what makes it the greatest? Why should this be so important?
Have you never had a favorite sports team? Football or hockey or rugby or something? A team that you loved to cheer for and support. And even when they didn't win their championship, even if they don't come close...they're still the "Greatest" because they've got more heart, more style, more something....
Of course we like to think of our own country as the greatest. We love it.
At the end of the day, it is just our opinions, and we don't expect to necessarily change that of others. I just cannot see why there is so much of the 'all or nothing' attitude here.
I don't think it's the expressing of opinions that has everyone riled. I think it's the brusque, insensitive manner in which they were expressed. I'd enjoy a chance to sit down and discuss the merits of the war and our actions against terrorism. But if you start by telling me we're all a bunch of megalomaniacs who bomb our own people in horrific ways just to have an excuse to attack other countries and steal their oil.....you're not likely to get a very sweetly worded response.
Get the idea? That's called freedom of speech, AND freedom of thought.
Yes. Freedom of speech. Speak on. But remember, everyone on this board has the same freedom, too. Don't be so surprised and offended when they use it.
Solutions? We often seem to get asked for solutions.
I don't think you need to be asked for solutions in order to offer them...if your arguments are valid. Opinions were certainly offered that were never asked for.
But an opinion people, we're still allowed that!
Of course you're allowed that! But anyone else is too. And in their opinion, your opinions are wrong. Are they "allowed" to think that? To say it?
Can they ALL be wrong?
To think that the majority opinion must, by definition, be right, is a very dangerous way to think. Actually...it's not THINKING at all. It's simply going along with the flow of the river as it follows the easiest course available to it.
What if we had taken Hitler out before he began ransacking Europe and murdering hundreds of thousands of people??? Would that have been a good thing? It's hard to imagine anyone thinking otherwise. BUT...if we had...would anyone then recognize it for the good thing it was? We'd be nothing but the "bully" who stomped on a German dictator because we didn't like him. He surely wouldn't have been so bad as to deserve that sort of treatment! And...we'd never know otherwise, would we? We'd just have to TRUST in the leadership of our country that they knew what they were doing.
Or should we have waited until Saddam finally had the weapons he craved and the opportunity to use them? Waited for that nuke to fall on some city...waited for some engineered disease to ravage an entire continent?
I'm glad we didn't wait.
Judy
-----
1.0 red cape gopher (Caesar)
0.1 gerbil (Whiskers)