Rheostats are a lot cheaper which hardcore snake fanatics don't use them except for a backup power source in which your thermostat is plugged into. The rheostat comes on 100% and goes off a degree above the desired temp and turns completely off therefore saving on the electric bill but the heat is on or off.
You are describing the difference between a proportional and non-proportional thermostat. A rheostat is basically a dimmer switch.
Here's the differences -
Rheostat (dimmer) - reduces the overall power going to the heat source. Therefore the light/tape will not run at full power and will only get partially as warm as at full power. These are great for preventing heat tapes from ever getting too hot. They don't measure the room temperature at all, they are simply on all the time.
Non-proportional Thermostat - these are temperature sensitive switches that turn on/off the heat source at a particular temperature. Therefore when the the temperature where the probe is place falls below a preset level, it turns on the heat source. The heat source stays on until the temperature at the probe heats up to a preset level. On good thermostats you can set the on and off points separately which allow you to determine the range during which it functions.
Proportional Thermostats work like regular thermostats, except that they have the ability to do what a rheostat does at the same time. When the temperature at the probe drops below threshhold, the thermostat sends just a little bit of power (as opposed to 100% like a regular thermostat) to the heat tape to get the temperature back up. It therefore uses less power and can tweak the temperature within a narrower range.
So what do you need? It depends.
I generally just have my heat tapes on an inline lamp dimmer (rheostat). I have those heat tapes plugged into a Ranco thermostat (non-proportional) so that it turns the tapes off when the temperatures get above 85° in the room (rarely happens). I generally set it and forget it. My heat tapes run at a reduced power as long as the room temps are under 85°. If I find the tapes are too warm, I turn down the rheostat.
I also use a non-proportional thermostat to control my auxillary room heater (oil filled heater) in the winter. The heater has its own thermostat, but they are famous for being unreliable so I use a Ranco thermostat as a backup to shut it off if it gets too warm.
I personally think proportional thermostats are a gadget. Yes they keep the temperature within 0.1 degrees constantly, but who cares? I don't think the snake really cares how close to 90° the heat tape is. If it is warm enough, they sit there, if it is too warm, they move. Their comfort zone is wider than 0.1°. If you have a reliable thermostat that keeps the temperature within 5° of your target temperature, I think the animals needs can be met perfectly.
The ones that have programmable night/day temperature differences are nice, but again I think it is probably overkill regarding the snakes' physiological needs.
-----
Chris Harrison
San Antonio, Texas