Hi there!
For the record, I'm not trying to be argumentative or personal.
I've always felt that if a person disputes something another person says, and they state their claim as if it were a fact, then it's common courtesy to provide some sort of proof.
It's very important to keep things in context, but I realize that sometimes it's difficult to see some things in the context of which they were presented because our minds are already thinking a different way. Happens to the best of us, even me.
Please allow me to quote an excerpt of my first post:
"I suggest offering a variety each time instead of a single type. But if you do offer a single type, "The Bearded Dragon Manual" recommends Romaine lettuce as the best all-around greens and I've found it to be true. But a variety is better."
Now then, in your previous post, the one to which this is a reply to, you said, "It is useful to help get stubborn feeders to eat because of the taste,..."
Please recall that the member was talking about his dragon being reluctant to eat greens. I cannot find where he asked what's the most nutritional green. So therefore, my post was well within context.
Also keeping in context, or not, is your latest comment; "...but it should never be offered exclusively..." For the record, I never said that it should. In fact, I said "a variety is better."
I'm not trying to be a smarty or be sarcastic, so if this comes across that way, I apologize. I'm just trying to point out the way I see things in this thread.
As for your comment: "I also don't remember reading in the Bearded Dragon Manual that Romaine lettuce is a good all round green to feed."
Sorry, but I can't help but feel you're calling me a liar on this one. But your clan won't see it that way, I'm sure. And I could be wrong about the way I feel about it. I very much dislike to be called a liar. Nobody can point out a single lie that I have told as a member of these forums, or can tell of one that I have told, period. Nobody. It's not my style.
I honestly can't help what you remember & what you don't. I suppose there's a chance that maybe you read an earlier version than the one I have stting in front of me right this minute. Those that have the same version I have know that I speak the truth. On page 57, the 2nd sentence of the 1st paragraph begins "The overall best green in our opinion is romaine..." "The Bearded Dragon Manual" (Vosjoli. Mailloux, Donoghue, Klingenberg & Cole)
I believe that statement is made in the context of getting dragons to eat greens because it is written under the 2 - 4 month old bearded dragon feeding guidelines, when they first mention feeding greens to dragons.
The nutrition data link you provided in your last post can be of use, just like I said the other link could. It is important to keep it in context, though. The percentages shown are based on human consumption, according to a 2,000 calorie daily diet. But still, the average person should be able to draw a reasonable conclusion, so I'm not discrediting it.
Are you aware that the nutrition data site lists different percentages for mustard greens & romaine lettuce than the 503extreme site? There is a discrepancy there. Not a big one, but enough to wonder which one is right.
I'm under the impression that you're thinking in the context of which green is the most nutritious overall. That is not the context that I posted my first reply in, nor is that the context of this thread.
There's one more thing I'd like to say. BDlvr and I exchanged a few e-mails and I think we've come to realize that even though we may view some things differently, we still have a lot of things we can agree on. Especially our main goal of improving the lives of Bearded Dragons. I believe we've set things behind us, wiped the slate clean and will carry on. I would like for you & I to do the same thing if you can. If not, I can understand.
Either way, I hope I'm through as far as this thread is concerned.
Have a great day!
Mike
(HappyHillbilly)
-----
Due to political correctness run amuck,
this ol' hillbilly is now referred to as an:
Appalachian American