Robert, you and I are thinking along the same lines, but I wanted to clarify some points.
>> As long as there are hides on both the cool and warm side, the snake is going to position itself in the enclosure based on its need for heat.
>>Now, if you have a hot side in a small enclosure that prevents a nice temperature gradient, therein lies a problem.
>>As long as there is an appropriately warm and cool side, the snake is going to position itself in the enclosure based on its requirement for heat.
All of the statements above support my reasons for continually advocating the use of at least a 20 gallon tank for hognoses, even for hatchlings. It does not matter how big the snake is, it is the size of the container that dictates the ability to provide a thermogradient.
>> you could have a hot side that reaches 100 degrees and that should not pose a problem. The snake will sense that its too hot and position itself at a place just outside the hottest part to achieve temps below 100.
The statement implies that hognoses do not prefer temperatures at 100° or more. I recommend temperatures around 95° simply because it is safer than attempting to get 100° and cooking the snake accidentally at 110°. The studies I have read have confirmed that hogs, in general, had been found basking with body temperatures at or near 100°. Granted they may be only basking at that temperature for a short time, but we do know that they prefer that temperature.
>>I highly doubt that a snake can differentiate between 85 and 95 degrees to the extent that it knows which spot to go to because that is the temp they experience in "the wild".
Agree with the "knowing what is a wild" part. However, a 10° difference is a huge difference in the metabolism of an ectotherm! On the centigrade scale, a 10° difference has an exponential effect. A 10° difference in a hibernating reptile can be the difference between starving to death and being at perfect homeostasis. I hope you are not suggesting that there is not a need to provide a specific temperature range on the hot side of the tank.
>>So, to make a long story short: if there is a temperature gradient, the actual temperature in a specific spot should not matter all that much.
I realize this may be a technical point, but the temperature in a specific spot does matter. If we know that (presumably) healthy hognoses in the wild prefer a body temperature of 100°, and a person keeping a hognose in captivity only provides an 85° basking spot, it is easy to assume that the captive snake will not be able to behaviorally reach their preferred body temperature... ESPECIALLY when the snake is sick (all animals WILL get sick and die, after all). Let us assume that a sick wild hognose will use a "behavioral fever" by basking a little bit longer and getting their body temperature up to 105° in order to fight off whatever infection. Relative to the wild hognose, the captive hognose is at a severe disadvantage since its temperature possibilities are far below what are available to the wild hognose. SO! The point of all this is to emphasize that captive herps should be provided a thermogradient, and be provided a temperature slightly warmer than "normal" so that whenever the animal gets sick, it has the ability to get warmer and get better. Who knows of how many issues with captive hognoses could be corrected just by providing a temperature that would be conducive to a "self-healing" by the snake!
-----
Virginia Herping
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/VaHS
Virginia Herpetological Society online store
http://www.cafepress.com/vaherpsociety
"The irrational fear of snakes is the only excuse a grown man has... to act like a complete sissy" - Colchicine