Travis.... yes it is a good idea to dust their food with a calcium/D3 supplement for breeding females in my opinion 3 or 4 times weekly, along with a multivitamin supplement 1 time weekly for lizards kept indoors on a regular basis. If you keep your collared lizards outside in natural sunlight on a regular basis still use the calcium and multi-vitamin supplements, but in this case use the calcium supplement without D3. I don't keep mine outside on a regular basis so I always use the one with vitamin D3. I use the same approach with babies and juveniles and the subadults and adults not breeding I use the calcium supplement twice weekly and the multi-vitamin/mineral supplement 1 time weekly. Has your female always shown the orangish/reddish nuptual blush when she ovulates, after mating and while she is carrying her eggs? (That is in previous breeding seasons?) The reason I ask is sometimes there are females that will ovulate and be ready for mating without showing colors - I had one a long time ago like that, but that's not the norm of course. But not using the calcium supplement in itself isn't why your female isn't showing colors yet.... she just isn't ready for breeding/mating yet. You have to really be patient with them. Sometimes within days or a couple of weeks after they come out of brumation adult/mature females will begin ovulating and showing the colors indicating readiness for mating/breeding with the males - even at that time if she isn't ready yet she will reject the male's advances/attempts at mating.... when she's ready they will mate. Other times it may take couple of months before the female begins ovulating and showing colors. Still there may be breeding seasons after brumation has been completed and the females won't ovulate/breed in that particular year. You may only get 1 clutch in a season or possibly multiple clutches, or even none at all, and still there may even be times when your females will even reabsorb their eggs, thus never laying them. What temperature and how long did you brumate your Collareds this past winter and when did you wake them up and are they eating with good appetites and have they put back on any of the weight they may have lost during brumation, are they in good health, how old, mature, or immature are they? I also think the way you gutload your insects prior to feeding your lizards is good too, they seem to be getting a good variety of nutrition with fruits and veggies and the calcium mix (does the calcium mix have food in it that contains a variety of vitamins and minerals for additional nutritional value - I suspect it does but was just wondering because that's important too?). Sorry I got long-winded but I hope this answers a lot of your questions and gives you some good insight.
Jeff