It's a very valid and interesting question about motivation and husbandry issues.
The first poster in the thread wanted something easier for himself. He also didn't want to get hassled about tiny cages because he didn't have the time, desire, or "resources" to do larger caging for all his animals. Soil/natural substrate seems like "too much work", and larger caging is "too expensive".
Other folks have brought up having dirty lizards in a soil cage before as well.
Other keepers like tile because it "looks better" to them.
I guess it comes down to the various reasons that folks keep reptiles. Different keepers have a different focus. Some keep lizards with a pet focus, keeper-centric.
Some keep lizards with a lizard focus, reptile-centric. Some keep lizards for a combo of reasons. Some kid themselves about why they keep lizards : )
20 years ago, my focus was strictly pet oriented. As Pro Exotics and my reptile career progressed, it became more reptile-centric.
My focus is not on a pretty setup, but rather a useful one for the animal itself. Not on a visually pretty hidespot, but on a short, tight, functional one. Lizards and monitors get dirty in a soil substrate, I suppose, but not so that you can't see their patterns.
If I need to do pics, I can rinse them off and they look beautiful, that works for me.
I would rather see folks keep reptiles with the animal's best interest in mind, rather than their own, but that is not always realistic, and again, different folks have different motivations for why, and how, they enjoy the hobby.
In the grand scheme of things, we ALL keep reptiles in small boxes, so it is all very relative, we all make choices and compromises, I suppose it just comes down to where you find that line : )
-----
robyn@proexotics.com
Pro Exotics Reptiles
