I don't have any experience with Johnson Controls, but I would definitely recommend the Herpstat over the Helix. We are using several Herpstat II's and Herpstat Pro's. The features on these are far better than the Helix.
The first thermostat we bought was a Helix, the second was a Herpstat II. The Helix blew the internal fuse, which I have yet to be able to find a replacement. Now, all of our cages are on Herpstats. Herpstats have a high and low temp alarm, power matching, sensor matching and night drop built in and Dion at Spyder Robotics is great to work with. When we got our first Herpstat Pro it wasn't maintaining temps at all. We contacted Spyder Robotics, the maker of the Herpstats, and sent ours in. They had it fixed and back in our hands within a week. This is the only problem we have had.
-----
Randy and Michelle
Art In Scales
(719) 439-4199
info@artinscales.com