Hey Kenny,
everyone in this forum for the most part are good people and have lots of experience. We speak from our own experiences, whether they be from the field or from the snake room, but nevertheless it's a good place to be in this forum most of the time. I'd like to think we'd want you, or anyone else for that matter, move forward in your husbandry endeavors and enjoy Lampropeltis ssp. as much a we do.
Having said that, it sounds like what you have provided for the pyro is most appropriate. I use aspen bedding myself and have also heard good things about Care Fresh from reliable friends, well, 'cept for jyohe......LOL.......again, we all have differing opinions and/or experiences given the number of combined years working with herps. Unfortunately, a number of substrate materials' prices have risen, so paper towels and newspaper are sometimes the way to go depending on one's individual budget.
My only concern is that this morph of pyro can sometimes go for quite a bit of coin.......a pyro that is only eating tails "assist-fed" SHOULD be (and this is MY opinion and personal practice) priced accordingly if it is not feeding voluntarily.
You observed SOME feeding response, so go with that as I'd suggested earlier. Let the lil buger settle in, and in a couple days place a small thawed pink on a piece of cardboard or even on the inside of a cleaned jar lid and see what happens. Keep us posted.
Can't wait for 2009 either......we'll talk again hopefully at the 11/30 White Plains show.

" alt="Image">
-----
Jerry Kruse 
"Fall is my favorite season in Los Angeles, watching the birds change color and fall from the trees."
David Letterman