Reptile & Amphibian Forums

Welcome to kingsnake.com's message board system. Here you may share and discuss information with others about your favorite reptile and amphibian related topics such as care and feeding, caging requirements, permits and licenses, and more. Launched in 1997, the kingsnake.com message board system is one of the oldest and largest systems on the internet.

Click here to visit Classifieds
Click for ZooMed
Click for 65% off Shipping with Reptiles 2 You

Question for Anthony McCain.....

joshhutto Dec 20, 2008 01:47 PM

There was a topic last week I believe regarding super stripes (like there isn't one every week, lol) in which you mentioned that the specter/whirlwind were possibly alelles of the yb. My question is have there been multiple breedings of Superstripe x normal to prove this or is it still a hypothesis? I will say that if it has been proven with multiple clutches, thank god!! I hope to be adding this morph into my collection this comming year and it will be nice to know that can't be that easily reproduced.
-----
Josh & Krysty Hutto
J&K Reptiles

Various Ball Pythons, boas, dogs, cats, fish, an amel tiger retic female, a couple sulcatas and a few other odds and ends.

a BAD dog is MADE not bred, support the American Pit Bull Terrier as the greatest breed of dogs on Earth!!!!!

Replies (18)

anthony james mc Dec 20, 2008 03:55 PM

Yes Josh that has been the case for all of us so far . The Crystal genetics is proving out in a similiar way too. Contrary to what we thought in the beginning of all this
It won't be like breeding with a Bumblebee for the Super Stripe or Crystal projects from what we now understand.

Super Stripe x Whirlwind/Specter = Super Stripes and Whirlwinds, with the 25% shot if it exists of making the Super form on the Whirlwind/Specter side (which that Super form would not carry any YB genetics since the 2 genes are on the same allele). In other words no such thing as a Super Whirlwind Yb or a Super Specter YB (whatever name you use for that other ingredient gene with several names) if the 2 base morphs are indeed alleles of each other.

Super Stripe x YB= Super Stripes with Ivories/YB's, not many plain ol' Yb's made either (1 in 8 odds I think) as a regular Yb would only be made when BOTH the Whirlwind gene is missed or not given from the Super Stripe parent and instead is automatically given it's copy of YB AND also the YB parent threw "normal" genetics from her two options into the mix with her contribution instead of a copy of YB (remember a normal can be made from YB x YB 25% of the time). If the YB gene lined up from BOTH parents obviously NO Whirlwind gene can

anthony james mc Dec 20, 2008 04:10 PM

this wasn't intended to be up here, go down a few lines ,the complete post is there. Sorry? Not sure what the heck I did, LOL. Anthony.

joshhutto Dec 20, 2008 04:16 PM

So that is a great thing to hear. no normal should ever be produced from a SS breeding. Breeding Ivory x superstripe would equal ivories and superstripes with that logic as well. Now that makes superstripe females very powerful.
-----
Josh & Krysty Hutto
J&K Reptiles

Various Ball Pythons, boas, dogs, cats, fish, an amel tiger retic female, a couple sulcatas and a few other odds and ends.

a BAD dog is MADE not bred, support the American Pit Bull Terrier as the greatest breed of dogs on Earth!!!!!

cfr Dec 21, 2008 07:16 AM

This may be elementary to those of you with more experience out there, but why the statement that this makes ss females very powerful? Why would they be more powerful than the males?

kinderman Dec 20, 2008 03:55 PM

Josh, I am sure Anthony would be able to add details if he so chooses. 3-4 clutches I believe --no Super Stripes. Super Stripe x Normal produces 25% Y.B. 25% Spector and 50% Normals -- I think???

Spector and Super Spector FEMALES will be coveted highly I would think. Good luck with your SS project !!!!
-----
Bill Buchman

anthony james mc Dec 20, 2008 04:01 PM

Yes Josh that has been the case for all of us so far . The Crystal genetics is proving out in a similiar way too. Contrary to what we thought in the beginning of all this
It won't be like breeding with a Bumblebee for the Super Stripe or Crystal projects from what we now understand.

Super Stripe x Whirlwind/Specter = Super Stripes and Whirlwinds, with the 25% shot if it exists of making the Super form on the Whirlwind/Specter side (which that Super form would not carry any YB genetics since the 2 genes are on the same allele). In other words no such thing as a Super Whirlwind Yb or a Super Specter YB (whatever name you use for that other ingredient gene with several names) if the 2 base morphs are indeed alleles of each other.

Super Stripe x YB= Super Stripes with Ivories/YB's, not many plain ol' Yb's made either (1 in 8 odds I think) as a regular Yb would only be made when BOTH the Whirlwind gene is missed or not given from the Super Stripe parent and instead is automatically given it's copy of YB AND also the YB parent threw "normal" genetics from her two options into the mix with her contribution instead of a copy of YB (remember a normal can be made from YB x YB 25% of the time). If the YB gene lined up from BOTH parents obviously NO Whirlwind gene can be present since they are Alleles and that's how you'd make the Ivories from this pairing. In otherwords I ALSO don't think it will be possible at all to make a Ivory Super Stripe, we thought it could be made at the start of the project , but since it's likely an allele situation that snake couldn't be made genetically if this info is correct.

Super Stripe x Normal= Whirlwinds/Specters and Yb's split about 50/50

Super Stripe x unrelated morphs= same results as bred to Normal but also add the other new morph if it visually "hit" or if the morph is recessive the het or possible het of other new morph again with the above 50/50 split of Whirlwinds and YB's in theory.

Crystal stuff would work out the same as above just using the lesser complex morphs (Mojave, Lesser, Butter, Phantom , etc) in place of how the YB gene worked on the above situations and the "Special" morph that makes the Crystal, working in a similiar manner as the Whirlwind gene does for the Super Stripe project. Both projects are allele situations respective to 2 seperate types of projects in my opinion . That's what's proven to be the case thus far , until somebody shows me different breeding results that's how I am looking at it.

Ps same gig would apply with the Crystal project as well, the Super Crystal would NOT carry ANY other genetics other than the "Special" morph if the "Special" is an Allele to the other Lesser complex morphs . There's only room for either a regular Blue Eyed Lucy (Super Mojave, Super Lesser, Super Phantom, etc) OR a Super Crystal with only the "Special" gene expressed in it's Super form and NOT room to put anything else in those Super forms if indeed they are alleles of each other. In other words like the Super Stripe you WON'T be able to make a Mojave Super Crystal , in that case it would either be a Super Crystal or simply put for ease of understanding a "Super Special" or a Super Mojave , Super Lesser, Super Phantom, based on what you were breeding with since we now know what the Super Crystal on it's own looks and it's different looking than the other Supers so it's preety easy to tell what Super you made. That's how I see it based on what's been hatched, that's it, nothing beyond that , so far anyway!

Top 2 pics are "Pastel" siblings to my Super Crystal and "Special" males. Last pic is the founding female Whirlwind for my line of Super Stripes.

Hope I answered your question adequately Josh!
Take care , Happy Holidays!

Anthony McCain.

LKirkland Dec 20, 2008 05:01 PM

"Super Stripe x YB= Super Stripes with Ivories/YB's, not many plain ol' Yb's made either (1 in 8 odds I think) as a regular Yb would only be made when BOTH the Whirlwind gene is missed or not given from the Super Stripe parent and instead is automatically given it's copy of YB AND also the YB parent threw "normal" genetics from her two options into the mix with her contribution instead of a copy of YB (remember a normal can be made from YB x YB 25% of the time). If the YB gene lined up from BOTH parents obviously NO Whirlwind gene can be present since they are Alleles and that's how you'd make the Ivories from this pairing. In otherwords I ALSO don't think it will be possible at all to make a Ivory Super Stripe, we thought it could be made at the start of the project , but since it's likely an allele situation that snake couldn't be made genetically if this info is correct."

Anthony....if you're saying that YB & Whirlwind are alleles of the same gene, wouldn't SS X YB yeild the following probabilities?

25% Whirlwind
25% YB
25% Ivory
25% SS
-----
Louis Kirkland
Cornerstone Reptiles

LKirkland Dec 20, 2008 05:05 PM

yield not yeild
-----
Louis Kirkland
Cornerstone Reptiles

anthony james mc Dec 20, 2008 06:05 PM

Yb is on both sides of the breeding your talking about so I don't think the numbers work out even all the way down like your saying. Ivory, Super Stripe and regular YB ALL are types of YB's. Keep in mind a regular WW would ONLY be made in that breeding when both parents put zero Yb copies in there and it picked up the WW side from the Super Stripe. 50% of the time a Super Stripe will throw a YB copy and 50% of the time it's a WW copy that it throws. 50% of the time the regular YB throws Normal and 50% it throws YB. So I think the odds of making a regular plain Ol' Whirlwind are less than 25% much like the odds of making a regular YB are also alot less than 25%. I'm just doing that all in my head but I'm thinking the 1 in 8 odds instead of 1 in 4 odds are right. Somebody else chime in , it's been a long day out here with a blizzard going on in the background with 30 m/p/h wind blowin!

Anthony McCain

RandyRemington Dec 27, 2008 07:24 AM

I think Louis is right on the four quarters split.

Basically you take the two possible ss contributions at 50% each for yb and ww and then multiply those by the two 50% chance contributions of the yb (normal or yb) to get the four 25% chances.

clintkb Dec 20, 2008 04:32 PM

Josh,
Today,I spoke with mark haas who is hatching a clutch of male superstripe to yellowbelly female and he has a funky Ivory in the clutch. He is going to wait til it sheds to make any guesses about the genetics. The general consesus is the superstripe is on the same alleles.BUT..... The FACTS are: weird things are happening out of superstripe clutches. For example: the Spectres dont look like normal spectres? yellowbellies are kind of strange looking. Mark has a good situation in that the breeding didn't involve multiple males. Hopefully, mark can shed some more light on the genetics of the superstripe project!!!!

anthony james mc Dec 20, 2008 05:43 PM

That could be interesting too, I'd like to think one could be made BUT that's about like saying this Super Crystal I have has Mojave in it and Clint you know that genetically doesn't make sence, not unless this Allele stuff really does involve some new way of genetic math that we have not seen yet. Exactly what does he mean by a weird Ivory? Mark , care to enlighten us here what exactly do you mean, weird as in how??? Does it look like the one I made last year, the one I now think may just be a Pastel Ivory based on the fact that a Pastel Yb along with my Super Stripe bred that same YB mom. Did Mark use a Pastel Yb male then switch over to a Super Stripe male, if so that may be what happened anyway? My Ivory was very weird for just a Pastel Ivory as a baby , that's why myself and others thought he may have been a Ivory Super Stripe since those that looked at him agreed he wasn't a typical looking Pastel Ivory at all. Since then the fact that no Super Stripes have been made from a Super Stripe x Normal it genetically didn't make sence that either a Super Whirlwind Yb or a Ivory Super Stripe could be made if they are morphs both on the same allele, you can't do that, or from what I was taught shouldn't be able to do that.. Furthermore, if that is the case why doesn't it work like that whenever A Super Stripe has been bred to a normal and not made any Super Stripes, we have had plenty of babies made that way now without making ANY Super Stripes?? Would seem more logical to me that he either had a Pastel YB in with her anytime prior to ovulation OR the YB mother wasn't just a regular YB at all and another gene is coming into play there from her NOT the Super Stripe and whirlwind end of it, she could just be a Yb carrying another gene in her, a gene that isn't the whirlwind gene at all. We've already seen ALOT of different versions of Ivories so that would make more sence than to say it's an Ivory Super Stripe, NONE of those weird Ivories have made Super Stripe babies, most have given up on that idea I think. I have an adult female Ivory here that has just about as much patttern on her as those grapite Ivories,t looks like somebody made hash marks all over her back with a pencil enought so that it makes her look really strange dwon her back, and she isn't no Ivory Super Stripe I'd bet you, That particular Ivory doesn't look AT ALL like the other regular Ivories I have here to compare her next to either. I'd be willing to say if Marks Ivory is weird that other gene in it isn't any type of whirlwind / Super Stripe making gene . If it did have the other whirlwind morph in it as an Ivory then the allele theory is not working out like most of us would think it should.

Randy Remington, any comments here?? Is this something that can be an outcome in a "cross over" situation ?

The pic is the "weird " Ivory I made, he is the one that has been breeding with my founding Whirlwind female, I think he'll prove out to just be another Pastel Ivory, guess if he's not and he's something more I may find out this coming season , and if that's the case .. comments Randy???? Something else you need to explain to us now?
Anthony McCain

mhaas91 Dec 21, 2008 11:38 AM

What was wierd about the ivory that I hatched out was that it had a super stripe head pattern and was very purplish. It didn't have a pastel ivory head. I have a pastel ivory and the head pattern is much different. The pastel ivory that I got from you Clint is one of the nicer one's I have seen so I think I am comparing a good animal. In the clutch I hatched super stripes, a couple of het ss's, and this wierd ivory male. I think I will know more when he sheds along with the rest of the clutch. This was from a super stripe male to a yellow belly female. I can post a picture once they are all out of the egg and shed.

In regards to whether a super stripe will reproduce itself I think there needs to be some additional breeding. I think we will know these year for sure. I did have a clutch from super stripe to normal (4 eggs) produce no super stripes. It is leaning toward the fact that a super stripe can't reproduce itself.

Mark

anthony james mc Dec 21, 2008 12:46 PM

Mark , I have 3 Pastel Ivories from the Bells and the "weird" Ivory I hatched out looked quite alot different than (and yes including the head markings on this one too) the other 3 Pastel Ivories I have from the Bells. I Have only produced a few babies from that odd looking Ivory so far but so far based on what he made I'm thinking he is likely a strange looking Pastel Ivory. Yes it would be nice if I was wrong and instead of a Pastel Yb ending up his dad , instead the Super Stripe ended up being his dad . That's the problem when you use more than 1 male on a female , makes it hard to know what you have until you unfold the animals genetics out by breeding it.

Just doesn't make alot of sence however, if Super Stripe x normal likely can't make a Super Stripe at all, then how can a Super Stripe to YB make an Ivory Super Stripe? Is having the YB in there on both sides allowing it to link up or something, is that possible? The genetics seems inconsistant to me with that thinking. Perhaps Randy, Paul or somebody that knows of bizzare genetic situations like this is following all this and can explain some of this a little better so it makes more sence as I'm not sure how this situation could end up working out like that?

Anthony McCain

joshhutto Dec 21, 2008 01:46 PM

Anthony, just send me that killer Ivory male and I'll do all the breeding needed to prove it out one way or the other, lol.
-----
Josh & Krysty Hutto
J&K Reptiles

Various Ball Pythons, boas, dogs, cats, fish, an amel tiger retic female, a couple sulcatas and a few other odds and ends.

a BAD dog is MADE not bred, support the American Pit Bull Terrier as the greatest breed of dogs on Earth!!!!!

RandyRemington Dec 27, 2008 07:41 AM

Anthony, I'm with you on this, if yellow belly and specter/whirlwind aren't alleles then it should show up with a super stripe X normal breeding producing a super stripe. As more of those breedings are done next year we should either feel more confident about the allele idea or see it disproved.

Seems like there have been quite a few weird ivories lately. A few theories:

1. Maybe there are several different similar looking alleles that we are calling yellow belly. With so many different imports they might not all be genetically exactly the same but being compatible and making ivory like animals tends to indicate they are alleles. Maybe breeding some of these weird ivories together you will eventually get some even weirder ivories that are homozygous for a new variation of the yellow belly.

2. Whatever the heck paradox is might be coming into play. There seems to have been quite a few of these balls that break the rules lately that might be mosaics of either two separate fertilized eggs or some combination of one egg and two sperm or some such a bizarre thing.

3. Maybe rather than alleles (different versions of the exact same gene) yellow belly and specter/whirlwind are mutations of two different genes that just happen to be linked by being very close together on the same chromosome and the first crossover just happened not to happen in super stripe X normal but super stripe X yellow belly. I don't think this is too likely for some reason but who knows. More breeding should help us figure it out.

4. Maybe ivory is just more variable than expected.

clintkb Dec 21, 2008 07:31 PM

Mark,

Thanks, i thought that male pastel ivory was pretty nice looking and i hope he produces tons of pastel superstripes for you. I didnt mean to put you on the spot with the weird ivory you produced. Maybe he is just an ivory and maybe not. I think the important thing is to share information. You are maybe the only person that has Bred a male Superstripe without using multiple males!!!! It gets confusing when there are multiple sires involved. The superstripe project is still a little confusing, even to those of us directly involved. I believe Anthony had a clutch with his weird Ivory and based on his clutch(small , but no superstripes) he is working with a pastel ivory. most of the superstripe project is understood, but when it comes to breeding the superstripe males and what to expect i guess only time will tell.

mhaas91 Dec 22, 2008 10:28 AM

Clint,

No problem. I was just waiting for the clutch to shed. After the first shed you can really tell a lot. I will tell you the super stripes produced in this clutch are the best I have produced. They have almost like spider heads. In this clutch I produced 3 super stripes, two het ss's, and the funky ivory. I am not a big fan of telling people that the genetics are this way or the other way until there are more super stripe to normal clutches produced without multiple males breeding the female. I think this year will tell a lot.

Mark

Site Tools