According to wikipedia-"In common parlance, if something is to be taken with a grain of salt, it means that a copious measure of skepticism should be applied regarding a claim; that it should not be blindly accepted and believed without any doubt or reservation."
Why should comments made about temps be doubted in any manner?
Further I addressed the original poster of the thread and provided advice in regards to 3 of the fundamentals of monitor husbandry; Heat, Humidity, and usable hides
HEAT:
-"it is a lot more efficient to heat an enclosed cage" NATE
- "Heck 200 isn't all that bad either. If your monitor uses it I'd allow those temps." NATE
- "I'm willing to bet you can get what you need for temps with a 45w" NATE
HUMIDITY:
-"Thought I saw an open top. You may be losing more water from that then you think and that may be why he is in the water. I just think that a lizard that is in the water so much that he is not thermoregulating properly is more concerned with safety and OR CONSERVING MOISTURE THAN WITH ENJOYING A SWIM." NATE
-" On another note if your nile is constantly in the water I would assess 2 things. humidity, or rather make sure you don't have excess ventilation" NATE
HIDES:
-"I just think that a lizard that is in the water so much that he is not thermoregulating properly is more concerned with safety and or conserving moisture than with enjoying a swim." NATE
-"make sure that you are providing useable hides throughout the cage that have their own temp gradients. I know they "like" water but baby niles are known to use the water bowl as a hide in the absence of suitable hides." NATE
As you can see I made no blanket statement as simple as give it 200F basking sites. 3 very important tools were addressed. All correlate with each other. Useable hides are also an important aspect of water conservation, even in an enclosed cage. Hides serve as a place to hydro-regulate if you will. A properly designed hide should trap water vapor evaporating from the substrate providing a higher "humidity" than surrounding areas in the cage.
Before you tell people to cast doubt and skepticism on another maybe you should read the posts in their entirety.
Nate