Reptile & Amphibian Forums

Thousands of exotic animals seized in Arlington

by DEBBIE DENMON / WFAA-TV

Originally printed at http://www.wfaa.com/news/local/Thousands-of-exotic-animals-seized-in-Arlington-79323622.html

ARLINGTON — It's being called the biggest animal seizure of its kind in the country. Authorities moved in to take custody of a many as 20,000 creatures from an exotic pet distributor Tuesday morning.

Arlington Animal Services served a civil seizure warrant on U.S. Global Exotics, a multi-million dollar business that acquires these creatures from all around the world — then sells them for premium prices.

The collection includes snakes, wallabys, tarantulas, turtles and hedgehogs.

"We're finding huge amounts of dead animals in with the living ones," said Jay Sabatucci of Arlington Animal Services. "We're finding turtles who are basically in a toxic soup of water and other dead turtles."

The Humane Society and the SPCA of Texas are among the organizations helping city officials try to collect and catalog the menagerie from the U.S. Global Exotics facility in the 1000 block of Oakmead Drive. Veterinarians from around the country and even one from Great Britain were flown in to provide their expertise into evaluation and treatment of the more exotic animals.

"We have consulted with some experts," Sabatucci said. "Some of the methods of keeping the animals are not within guidelines. There are animals in there literally starving to death, not being fed. There are animals in conditions where the environment is either too cold or too warm for them."

U.S. Global Exotics will likely be shut down all day Tuesday as the seizure continues. No criminal charges have been filed against the firm, which — according to its Web site — has been importing and exporting exotic animals for 11 years.

The Web site claims that U.S. Global Exotics is licensed by U.S. Department of Agriculture, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and by the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department.

"I'm a dog man myself, so it's hard for me to understand how someone would like something exotic like a wallaby or a tree sloth," Sabatucci said. "But there are people who wish to have these types of animals, and they will pay top dollar to have them."

Officials said the seized animals would first be removed to an undisclosed location to evaluate their conditions. If a court awards the animals to the city, the survivors will be shipped to places where they will be properly cared for.

E-mail ddenmon@wfaa.com
www.wfaa.com/internal?st=print&id=79323622&path=/news/local

Try this link for some insight on this: http://pjboosinger.viviti.com/entries/general/peta-drove-that-panel-truck
jsc
-----
"As hard as I've tried, just can't NOT do this"
John Crickmer

This is the same guy whose transshipments of captive bred baby water turtles (primarilly Trachemys and Pseudemys) were used for the fraudulent data of/for those Hell-bent on shutting down Turtle Hobbyists in Texas a couple of years ago. Bunch of bogus data. I got the USF&W documents through the Freedom of Information Act to prove my point.
The figures those people were throwing around in the press had nothing to do with the export of Texas Chelonians to Asia for food. The only one sending Texas Turtles to China as food was Bayou Bob Poppellwell, with his Snappers, Softshells, and Red-eared Sliders. He got a free pass. He's still in business, as far as I know.
When facts don't matter. It's all P.R. and spin. Just a bunch of emotional drivel.
So long as people choose to allow others to do their thinking for them, we're all sunk.
jsc

-----
"As hard as I've tried, just can't NOT do this"
John Crickmer

"If you're amongst those who wonder what PETA's real agenda is. Read their own request in their CI's affidavit in the Arlington seizure matter. "Wherefore, the Affiant requests the humane euthanasia of all seized animals, as deemed necessary by a licensed veterinarian, in order to prevent suffering." They'll argue it doesn't mean quite that but indeed it does and it's telling that the animals have all been whisked away to a secret location to be "treated" by THEIR veterinarians."

Source: http://pjboosinger.viviti.com/entries/general/peta-says-kill-them-all

"Mark Bass is the PETA “agent” who signed the affidavit supporting the warrant for this seizure. He says he has worked there for 7 months. Yet he and Arlington Animal Control chose to do this seizure 9 days before Christmas. Was there no abuse for 6 months or did they carefully choose the time knowing that the hearing had to be within 10 days and the courts have vacation schedules? I suspect there was little or no abuse of these animals at all except what may have been done to them by Mr. Bass. I think they most definitely chose their timing carefully and without regard to the fact that these animals would be subjected to low temperatures for extended times. I think they are on a crusade and have no care whatsoever for the animals which are just a tool in their crusade.

And who is Jay Sabatucci, the face of Arlington Animal Control in this seizure (and likely in future animal seizures)? Jay graduated from the University of Texas at in 1979 and has a teaching certificate (no idea what his degree is in). “He has been in the animal welfare industry since 1984”. He worked for HSUS from 2002 to mid 2009 but I’ve been unable to determine what he was doing between 1984 and 2002. It certainly appears to me that he is in animal rights rather than animal welfare and there IS a difference, a BIG difference."

Source: http://pjboosinger.viviti.com/entries/general/cronysim-in-animal-seizures-arlington-a-case-on-point

Conflict of interest. Self serving individual looking for a new career and a promotion, perhaps.

HOUSTON-CHRONICLE (Texas) 28 December 09 Attorney: PETA worker neglected snakes in his care
http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/ap/tx/6790880.html

STAR-TELEGRAM (Fort Worth, Texas) 28 December 09 PETA worker neglected job, attorney says (Susan Schrock)
Arlington: Attorneys for U.S. Global Exotics accused an employee Monday of intentionally neglecting animals at the north Arlington business to further his agenda as an undercover investigator for the animal-welfare group PETA.
Lance Evans, an attorney representing owners Jasen and Vanessa Shaw, said Howard Goldman, who was working for PETA, could have done more to provide food, water and care for the animals that he said were being mistreated.
Instead, he chose to secretly take photos and make daily reports to send to PETA, the attorney said. Evans also pointed out that Goldman had never contacted federal, state or local authorities about his concerns during his seven months there.
"He was more concerned about helping PETA achieve its goal of putting U.S. Global out of business than actually aiding any animals that he felt were in distress," said Evans, who added that Goldman investigated the company without a license, a violation of state law.
The company is battling to regain custody of more than 26,000 animals seized by the city Dec. 15 after Goldman turned over evidence outlining what he described as animal cruelty at the Internet-based animal wholesaler’s facility.
An Arlington Municipal Court judge is expected to decide custody of the animals this week.
Goldman testified last week that he had conducted other undercover investigations for animal welfare groups and had been asked by PETA to apply for a job at U.S. Global Exotics to investigate conditions at its Arlington facility. PETA paid him $135 for each day he turned in a report while working at the firm as snake caretaker.
Evans questioned Goldman on why he did not follow a posted list of duties in the snake room and let snakes go for weeks without food or water or clean cages, as he had testified.
Goldman said he did everything he could for the animals but that the owners would not pay for the food, medical care and other supplies he requested. He said 1,500 to 3,000 snakes were under his care at any given time.
"We never had the proper amount of food. The snakes would go two or three weeks without even being offered food," Goldman said. "There were days I found hundreds of snakes dead."
Paul Boiko, another U.S. Global employee, testified Monday that most animals were fed and watered regularly and that a veterinarian visited the business once a week.
He acknowledged that some animals were not fed before being packaged to avoid problems during shipping. Certain animals, such as turtles and iguanas, were kept in cold conditions to force hibernation so they wouldn’t eat or move much, a practice he said he is standard in the industry.
Linda Frank, an attorney for the city of Arlington, questioned Boiko about whether other reported practices at the business were humane. Boiko testified that he had packaged more than 400 iguanas on Dec. 2 to be shipped to Egypt and had left them in their crates for about two weeks without food or water, waiting for the order to go through.
The order was eventually canceled Dec. 14 and, when animal welfare officers opened the crates during the raid Dec. 15, they found more than half of the animals had died.
It was the Shaws’ decision to leave the animals in the crates, Boiko said.
Boiko was also asked by the city about the company’s standard form of euthanasia, which reportedly involved putting sick or injured animals in a freezer.
"Do you think it’s humane to put animals in the freezer to die?" Frank asked him.
"If I had no other option," Boiko said. "What do you want me to do, to step on their heads?"
U.S. Global, which is closed, provided animals primarily to pet stores but had also done business with zoos in Fort Worth, Dallas, San Antonio and Nashville, said Boiko, who has worked for the company about six years.
Boiko testified that he found it suspicious that the city raided the company early in the morning, before employees had time to clean the cages or do their regular shopping for food.
Animal welfare officers reported finding only a few boxes of crickets, a bag of carrots and some moldy lettuce to feed more than 26,000 animals at the business.
Update: On Tuesday morning, Municipal Court Judge Michael Smith admonished attorneys for U.S. Global Exotics for attempting to have the city’s key witness in the case arrested.
A private investigator working for attorney Lance Evans called 911 on Monday from the court to report that former employee Howard Goldman had admitted under oath that he was operating as a private investigator without a license, a violation of state law.
Goldman has testified that he was secretly investigating animal cruelty on behalf of the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals during his seven months of employment at the north Arlington exotic animal wholesaler.
Officers arrived at the court to investigate the report but Goldman was not arrested.
Evans, who represents U.S. Global owners Jasen and Vanessa Shaw, declined to comment Tuesday morning on the incident.
The Shaws are battling to regain custody of more than 26,000 animals seized by the city Dec. 15 as part of an ongoing animal cruelty investigation.
Linda Frank, an attorney for the city of Arlington, said she was disappointed that U.S. Global’s attorneys would attempt to have a witness arrested to gain an edge during the civil hearing, which is now in its fifth day of testimony.
Smith is expected to decide custody of the animals, mostly reptiles, this week.
http://www.star-telegram.com/804/story/1857213-p2.html

STAR-TELEGRAM (Fort Worth, Texas) 29 December 09 Zoo employee testifies that he never saw animals mistreated at Arlington business (Susan Schrock)
Arlington: A Fort Worth Zoo employee who bought and sold animals for himself at U.S. Global Exotics testified Tuesday that he never saw animals being mistreated at the north Arlington business.
Mike Doss, who was not representing the zoo, disputed the testimony of witnesses for Arlington that the business improperly housed animals and denied them food, water and veterinarian care.
The owners of U.S. Global, an Internet-based exotic-animal wholesaler, are trying to regain custody of more than 26,000 animals seized by the city Dec. 15 during an animal cruelty investigation. Tuesday was the fifth day of the custody hearing before Municipal Judge Michael Smith.
"I was impressed," Doss said of what he saw during regular visits to the business since 2006 to buy animals or sell those he had raised at home.
"They obviously invested a lot of money in their caging systems and how they took care of their animals."
Doss, who cares for coldblooded land animals at the zoo, said there are several plausible reasons why some of the snakes, lizards and turtles seized from the business appeared emaciated or sick. Most animals caught in the wild are not screened for illnesses or parasites before they are shipped to distributors, and the travel itself or exposure to a new environment can affect animals’ appetites, he said.
He concurred with testimony from U.S. Global employees that it is not unusual or inhumane to force hibernation for certain animals, such as lizards and turtles, by keeping them in low temperatures or to not feed animals before shipping so they don’t bloat or regurgitate during transport.
City investigators have testified that some animals were not fed for weeks at a time and that the company did not have enough food to care for the number of animals in stock.
Doss said he is also concerned about whether animal welfare officers harmed some of the temperature-sensitive animals during the raid, which occurred on a day that the high temperature was 44.
"I thought it was horrible to drag coldblooded animals out of a warm building on such a cold day," Doss said. "The shock of the temperature change could have killed them alone."
More than 1,000 animals have died since the seizure, but animal welfare workers attribute those deaths to the effects of neglect at the business, not the move. City attorneys said the vehicles used to take the animals to their temporary home were climate-controlled.
Doss testified that some of the conditions shown in photographs and videos during the hearing did appear to be inhumane or inappropriate, including photos of hundreds of baby turtles being stored in boxes, hundreds of iguanas that died after being left in shipping crates without food or water for two weeks, and footage of an employee shaking tree frogs out of the narrow opening of a plastic soft drink bottle. Doss said he does not condone U.S. Global’s method of euthanizing animals by placing them in a freezer to die.
However, Doss said, he was concerned that some of the situations might have been staged by former employee Howard Goldman, who took some of the photos.
Goldman, the city’s key witness, testified last week that PETA had asked him to apply for a job at U.S. Global Exotics to investigate conditions there.
PETA paid Goldman $135 for each day he turned in a report while working as a snake caretaker for seven months.
Doss said he discovered during a visit that Goldman had mislabeled some snakes as indigo snakes, an incident he now finds suspicious because those are an endangered species that U.S. Global does not have a permit to have.
Attorneys for U.S. Global Exotics were admonished Tuesday by the judge for trying to have Goldman arrested.
A private investigator apparently working for attorney Lance Evans called 911 on Monday from court to report that Goldman had admitted under oath that he was operating as a private investigator without a license, a violation of state law. Officers arrived at the court to investigate, but Goldman was not arrested.
Evans, who represents U.S. Global owners Jasen and Vanessa Shaw, declined to comment about the incident.
Linda Frank, an attorney for Arlington, said she was disappointed that U.S. Global’s attorneys would try to have a witness arrested to gain an edge during the civil hearing.
Smith is expected to decide custody of the animals, mostly reptiles, as soon as Thursday.
Zoo employee testifies that he never saw animals mistreated at Arlington business

This Goldman fellow certainly has an agenda. Obviously not unbiased. Certainly a conflict of interest if he is being paid by the daily "incidences" he reports to his handlers.

If I understand the testimony correctly, he was hired by Global Exotics as a "Veterinary Technician" and if the animals indeed were not receiving proper "Veterinary Care", I should think he would be the culpable party in this case.

Certainly, without a doubt, the animals will suffer much more, with much higher mortality, while in the care of those self appointed saviors. They have no credentials.

By the way, on a side note, I did not see any unhealthy or abused/neglected animals being removed from Global Exotics on the seizure video I watched.

Whether or not the Court recognizes these facts and returns the animals to Global Exotics, only time will tell. If I were a betting man and history was any indication, I'd have to be a skeptic and say no.

We shall see.
jsc
-----
"As hard as I've tried, just can't NOT do this"
John Crickmer