Reptile & Amphibian Forums

Welcome to kingsnake.com's message board system. Here you may share and discuss information with others about your favorite reptile and amphibian related topics such as care and feeding, caging requirements, permits and licenses, and more. Launched in 1997, the kingsnake.com message board system is one of the oldest and largest systems on the internet.

Click for 65% off Shipping with Reptiles 2 You
Click for ZooMed
Click for 65% off Shipping with Reptiles 2 You

Captive bred monitors from Indonesia

mampam May 28, 2010 12:42 PM

According to: Nijman, V. and Shepherd, C. R. (2009).
Wildlife trade from ASEAN to the EU:
Issues with the trade in captive-bred
reptiles from Indonesia.
TRAFFIC Europe Report for the European
Commission, Brussels, Belgium.

They looked at facilities claiming to breed various reptiles for the pet trade. They looked at two monitor species, Varanus prasinus and V. timorensis, and concluded for both: "It therefore appears that all specimens of this species exported as captive-bred are in fact wild-caught".

I hope this doesn't come as shocking news to too many people.
-----
Mampam Conservation

Replies (8)

twillis10 May 29, 2010 02:33 AM

Im sure this is the case all to often. As long as someone says they are captive breed most people dont care. I know of several petstores that sell tons of wild cought to the public. as im sure most of you do.

I only support wild cought if they are used for breeding, to help have a stable captive breed population for an animal that will be heavily imported anyways. Taking an animal out of its natural habitat just to keep as a pet just doesnt seem ok. Espescially not when you can probly find it captive breed. In this day and age if you just want a pet and not a breeder there are plenty of captive breed animals to chose from.

I get really fired up about the topic and could go all day, but ill leave it at that.

twillis10 May 29, 2010 02:35 AM

Sorry if I got a little off the subject. My mind went a million different ways after reading the post.

moe64 May 29, 2010 07:33 AM

I agree with you,but till they lower quotas and raise prices there is no motivation to take them from disposable pets to captive bred-only certain species with investment qualities are atempted to be bred.I know they are hard to breed but if species like Varanus prasinus are still being imported to supply demand-the future is bleek.And this is a species people want to keep,people who are serious would not have a problem paying for captive bred.
The good news is these forums that promote people if you are going to buy wild caught buy in pairs or groups to breed.It is easy to say not to buy wild caught if it is a species that are being bred in captivity.In the near future i'm sure species like Halmahera Scrub Pythons(Morelia tracyae) are going to be bred by dedicated hobbist to ease demand for WC.
This is nothing new i have just regurgitated what has been discussed numerous times on many a forums thanks Moe

mampam May 30, 2010 04:12 AM

www.traffic.org/species-reports/traffic_species_reptiles26.pdf
-----
Mampam Conservation

FR May 31, 2010 09:26 AM

Hi Daniel,
I think this is a great subject. Specially with your experience.

It appears our governments do not want conservation of any wild animals, muchless monitors.

If we leave this type of regulation to the governments, they will band(make illegal) everything. They have no idea what is better for the world and the people in the world or how to do it.

They will take everything people have a passion for and leave us standing on street corners with no instrument to play.

Daniel you have seen many sides to this subject, and you know, some of the answers, YET you let ego and academics stand in the way.

There are people who are good at breeding these animals and have the ability(facilities) to breed these animals. There are people who study these animals(you and your peers) and there are people who regulate these animals(governments) Yet all fight against eachother, tooth and claw. All the while the animals lose ground in nature. Daniel you know this, yet you take part in the confusion. You are actually contributing to the mass collecting of wild monitors. You are by supporting the confusion between academics, private breeders and zoos.

The parts are in place to lower the demand for wildcaught varanids. There are folks like me who have the KNOWLEDGE and facilities to captive produce these animals. There are zoos that could produce the founder stock for private industry. There are academics that could gather information to sustain these animals in captivity so that the need to TAKE wild caughts is so low that it would not impact dwindling populations.

Yet all these parts work against eachother and the ANIMALS SUFFER. All these parts BLAME the governments, REALLY Daniel, do you think we take no responsibility in this??????????

The little Battle we play is part of this. Your peers(academics) are so worried that I may know MORE then them, they fight tooth and claw against me and my "puppy mill". These arguements, have caused you/them, to lose track of the goal.

If you want to lower the demand for wild caughts, you know there MUST be a value to humans to keep them intact in nature. Its the percieved VARANID PUPPY MILLS that have the ability to lower the demand for wild caughts. Its also these private breeders that could benefit from a place to obtain founder stock.

Zoos could also benefit and actually take part in conservation, if they could excess animals into the captive breeding industry. Yet now they do not because of stupid reasons like industry is commercial. Sir, zoos are commercial, all they do is promote GATE. Their function, their design, and their intent is commercial. Even conservation is used as a advertising tool to promote GATE. Without GATE, zoos Close up. They are the same. I know, I built the dang things.

I had this arguement with the folks at a Texas zoo. They would say, we are a conservation institute. Then I would say, how many animals of a species of concern do you house? We have 2.3. but if we had room we would have more. And we do not produce them because we do not have the space. Hmmmmmmmmmmm is that conservation? I would call a zoo a conservation institute if the whole zoo was devoted to one species. That is, if they had hundreds even thousands of a species of concern. That would be conservation. Not 2.3 static animals on display.

So Daniel, academics like you lay claim to being educated and smart, so please Daniel put that college education to use, You folks should Bring all these estranged parts together into a working unit and build a conservation tool that benefits the animals in nature and the public and support economy.

I am picking on you because we have had conservations in the past, You stated that in order to preserve these animals in nature, they must have a VALUE to the local people, and they must have a value to national and international economy. If they do not, they will disappear. The need to take wild animals, IS THE TOOL THAT WILL PRESERVE WILD ANIMALS. Its up to you SMART guys to figure that out.

The REALITY is, the different parts of a system do not have to think alike, or understand the animals in the same way. All they have to do is work together, each doing what they are "SMART" enough to do.

So Daniel, as a educated academic, why don't you take the bull by the horns and MANAGE the different parts needed to make a benefitual system work. If you did, we could all do what we DO BEST. Again with reality, its not about who knows what or whos smarter, its ALL ABOUT DOING SOMETHING. Daniel "do" something.

We private breeders KNOW how to work these animals in captivity, many of us have the facilities to do so. Yet all we get is grief and opposition from Academics, zoos, and universities. So what were you saying Daniel? Why did you come here with your post??????Cheers

VaranusTattus Jun 16, 2010 01:13 AM

Well put FR... I thank Daniel for his studies but we are also the ones that support captive breeding programs. Zoos could definitely help us out more if they wanted to. They are very commercial. I am a little distraught right now. I just got back from Afghanistan and tried to watch Animal Planet. It made me irate at how people die for our so called freedoms and every time I come back from overseas America has more restrictions, laws, penalties, cameras, also less rights and freedoms! I live out in the desert to stay away from these over opinionated people but I am glad to help or stand up for anymore attempts at taking away our rights and freedoms!

mampam Jun 16, 2010 02:49 AM

I'm not sure there are many people who are good at breeding Indonesian monitor lizards, other than the species that live outside wet forest (like timorensis and panoptes). The vast majority of the Indonesian wet forest monitors for sale are wild caught still.

The point is simply that lots of lizards for sale are supposedly "captive bred" in Indonesia, there's been little proof either way whether it was true or not, and this is the first evidence I've seen of somebody actually going to the "farms" to see what the truth is.

By all means let's discuss it when we meet, but I have neither the time nor inclination to get involved in more unpleasant online stuff with you.
-----
Mampam Conservation

jobi Jun 05, 2010 07:21 PM

np

Site Tools