Absolutely Ed. I am not knocking anyone who wants to buy one anywhere in the U.S. I just think everyone needs to understand fully what it is they are getting into.
As far as numbers showing up on TH's doorstep you would be surprised. I suspect that country wide there are alot that end up being unwanted too. I am not trying to over dramatise and call anyone who sells a sulcata and evil wrongdoer (they're not) but I wouldn't just brush off the unwanted animal issue as virtually non-existent or small either.
True not everyone gets rid of theirs but I think it takes a pretty devoted person in a climate like New York to take on a sulcata for life. (which will be longer than the person who buys one!!). Hell for that matter I have drooled over your gorgeous Aldabras time and time again only realize how impossible a task THAT would be.
Another factor that we have no record of is how many JERKS get these animals and don't take care of them and end up killing them. Some idiots even dump their sulcata's on Long Island thinking that they will be able to run free and survive.
Personally I love 'em. They are cute, friendly and responsive but again more than I would be able to handle. Not really interested in having something that eats like a horse and therefor "processes" like one as well living in my house at 100lbs for six months out of the year.
I think there is a tortoise for everyone in this country that wants one. You really do have to do your homework though so you know what YOU individually are capable of dealing with AND are able to give the best life too. If that is a sulcata -- I say go for it.
I raise parrots (have for many years) Folks come by wanting to get a macaw or an amazon parrot that have never had a parrot before. Most of them take one look and see that huge beak reaching over to grasp their arm and climb on and end up leaving with a cockatiel. Ya just need to know As much as possible BEFORE purchasing.
PS -- Do you still have any of those nice cherry head redfoots?
Now those are torts I can live with??