Joe,
I hope you don't interpret this as a personal attack or anything other than what it is - a mere discussion about Savs, not meant to offend, but inform & inquire, to share.
I know exactly where you're coming from about trying to replicate nature in their feeding habits. For the most part I agree with you. I could make one heck of a case for either side of this issue. My problem with this is when we pick/choose to allow a change here & there, but not in other areas. Yes, I'm guilty of it, too.
In your first post you stated: "I always adapt to my animals, I never try to make them fit into my life."
* Instead of us living in the wild to be near the animals we love, we move the animals into small cages within our manmade homes - to make them fit into our lives.
* We give them light bulbs in place of sunlight.
I could go on but don't have enough time right now.
"If you don't want to talk stomach contents look at how short most monitors lives are in captivity.(not just savannas) Most of the people I know who have success breeding monitors don't have fat overweight lazy animals. Why is it savannas are raised like this though? You don't have to take my word for it, just look at the facts."
Joe, can you post any links to studies that support your claim that rodents are the cause of Savannah Monitors' short average lifespan in captivity? The reason I ask is that most of the people I've seen say that obesity in Savs is the result of rodents have either no personal experience with them or their experience is limited to a couple of years, max.
From your posts in this discussion it looks like you're making a big jump by concluding that Sav obesity is due to rodents while ignoring the many other factors involved.
Here is what I believe to be the leading cause of Sav obesity: Poor husbandry, in general (excluding prey type) & the quest for “Big”.
* Savs are the cheapest & most easily obtained monitor. Making what beginners think to be the perfect chance to have a monitor. I'd venture to say that, at the time of purchase, at least 75 - 90% of the people who buy them don't have a clue as to what their setup is supposed to be.
* Don’t forget about how so many people want something “big”. They don’t just want a monitor, but a "big" monitor. A big lizard. A lot of people power-feed their captives just to make ‘em big. I’m constantly fighting this with Burmese Python owners, and it’s prevalent in nearly all captive animals. Many experienced keepers are guilty of this. I’ve seen a reptile industry leader with a retic so fat that it looked like a Burm. It’s ludicrous. But I guess it sells.
Why Savs aren't in the captive-bred mainstream?
* Largely due to the fact that the overwhelming majority of Sav keepers are too inexperienced.
* Competition - Who wants to spend all the time & money to produce $100 - $200 CB Savs when most people won't spend more than 20 - 40 bucks for one?
* Most of the people that have bred them have only had a few decent runs, at the most. Seems to me that Savs may be harder to continually reproduce in captivity than other monitors.
I do think your posts in this discussion are worth your effort and I hope that this discussion will jar someone into really digging in and experimenting. We need more actual research. My personal Sav studies that I'm working on came from an obesity discussion here years ago. I set out to dispel the myths and seek the truth, for myself, not just taking someone's word for it.
Thanks for chipping into the discussion!
Later!
HH
-----
Due to political correctness run amuck,
this ol' hillbilly is now referred to as an:
Appalachian American

www.natures-signature.com