I'm not mad at you, open minds/views are always welcome here
As long as posts are not meant in a harmful/aggressive way, I think different views are always good to disucss a topic - that is how we all learn.
You def have a very interesting point and under different circumstances I would agree with you completlely. Such as using anitbiotics or "cleansing" food/meds that wipes out their internal parasites and "bacteria" that occur naturally. I def agree with you on that and will never use that on our stock.
However, for certain diseases/illness, no I don't think keeping them away from disease/parasites is harful to them in the long run I think it's common sense. I don't equate it to the human flu where your immune system never gets exposed to it therefore you become weaker around it. the flu doesn't normally kill humans and or cause their body to become infested internally with organisms at high levels that should not be there.
Hookworms, pinworms, roundworms, and so on are all diseases/illness that can and will kill your dragon - especially at high levels. I do not agree with "preventive cleansing" with the products out there - I think you are probably dead on with that point. But when a dragon is raised under normal circumstances and their enclosure is kept as clean as possible I don't think that causes them "undo harm." Have to remember, as hard as we try, they will always be exposed to something in their crix, air, worms, greens, even the air and us humans. It's not like we have them living in a bubble.
Yellow fungus disease that is now creeping up here and there is becoming a perfect example of this "debate." I won't go into the details here, Cheri is the expert on that, but the point is spreading that disease by contact is never good and is deadly. Tiny babies through adults can get that and it's got nothing to do with a strong or depleted immune system. To my knowledge it's a skin disease that spreads through contact and/or rubbing together. There is no way to "prepare" a dragon to fight that off.. it just happens when contact is made. That is why I am very paranoid about touching dragons from "unchecked" stock.
Many times the dragons can get weaker immune systems because they are fighting off these parasites which leaves them open to respiratory infections, coccidia level increases bc they are stressed out, malnutrition, dehydration, and a host of other problems. Coccidia is always present and at low levels is not too bad, but when stressed or exposed to new outbreaks, can reach dangerous levels that will send dragons down hill big time.
As far as breeding dragons, it's a known fact that breeding any dragons stresses out the female and opens her up to problems. That's why it's important to have them at certain levels before they are bred. I don't think dragons that are kept in sanitary conditions are "producing" weaker dragons that are more open to contracting diseases and such.
I believe the opposite is true. I believe by having strong healthy adults kept and raised in the best possible environement produces strong babies with strong immune systems that as they grow are able to fight off problems and/or disease as they grow. That is if you start with proprer breeding stock - some of the "breeder dragons" i see out there I just cringe when I see them. Very sad.
Your point is very interesting, and if anyone can prove that I am wrong, that would be a very interesting topic to discuss. Again, I think you are right about preventive biotics cleansing out their systems - there is always a certain level of coccidia/parasites/bacteria that is present in dragons - but when exposed to an outbreak it overloads that balance and takes over the safe level which the healthy dragon had maintained - that is why I think strong healthy dragons are more important then smaller/weaker dragons.
I will contine to keep all of my dragons out there under sanitary conditions and away from any illness/disease that I can. That is how we raise, breed, and sell our stock. But hey, if anyone reading this wants to buy a dragon from a breeder that has their dragons exposed to illness/disease, just let me know I know a ton out there lol.
brandon
-----
Dragons by Nature