Reptile & Amphibian Forums

Welcome to kingsnake.com's message board system. Here you may share and discuss information with others about your favorite reptile and amphibian related topics such as care and feeding, caging requirements, permits and licenses, and more. Launched in 1997, the kingsnake.com message board system is one of the oldest and largest systems on the internet.

Click here to visit Classifieds
Click for 65% off Shipping with Reptiles 2 You
Click here to visit Classifieds

white-walled vs. white-sided

brianm616 Feb 26, 2013 10:43 PM

this isn't a genetics question and i don't care if they're compatible traits.

what i am interested in is knowing why there's such a huge price disparity between a white-sided brooks and a white-walled speckled?

as far as i can see, speckled's are about three times as expensive as brooks.

and of course i'm more interested in getting a speckled - since i work with 3-4 ft snakes and don't want to deal a 5 ft monster who may eat my cat

thanks in advance.
-----
i work with tri-colored west mexican lampropeltis. some morph, some hobby, and some locale.

everyone is entitled to their options, but no one's opinion will ever change how i feel about the snakes i keep and breed.

Replies (20)

thomas davis Feb 27, 2013 12:56 AM

history. the ww holbrooki have traceable history many of the first were locale specific of course once they hit the market many were and since been bred to holbrooki from many differant locales and im sure ssp. as well.
ive always felt the ws fla. were created from the ww speck but i do not know that to be true or if they are even combatable.
i will say its a cool mutation.

,,,,,,,,thomas davis
-----
Morphs... just like baseball cards BUT ALIVE, how cool is that???

my website www.barmollysplace.com

GerardS Feb 27, 2013 08:33 AM

We have have been agreeing a lot lately. Good job!
-----
Gerard

"How awesome would it be to deny the prophecy?"

www.livebaitclip.com

GONE FISHING!!!

Nokturnel Tom Feb 27, 2013 09:05 AM

I introduced the Specks to the Hobby, there is no way in hell that white sided Brooksi come from the Specks. The original wild caught was bred by Terry Vandeventer and I aquired the first group he sold to anyone.
The pricing on white sided snakes was botched... white side Brooksi are killer, but the specks smoke them. Whiye Sided Axanthics came soon after White Sides if not immediatly. For whatever reason that hurt it.... the price was the same.... bad marketing.
The original White Wall was wild caught.... the original White Side Brooksi was not... they "popped out" of axanthics.... yet that never happened to anyone else.....
Terry V and I came up wit 700 bucks a pop for the original white walls.... low ballers followed us and took the much harder to care for Specks and wrote it off as no big deal.
The time, and effort it took to get that white wall into the hobby was no big deal to anyone but a few people... it has a lot to do with why I will never go through it again.
Tom Stevens
-----
TomsSnakes.com
twitter.com/TomsSnakes

DMong Feb 27, 2013 10:17 AM

"the original White Side Brooksi was not... they "popped out" of axanthics"

So now there are three very conflicting stories of how the WS floridana first came about....gotta love it!

So there is what you just stated about how they originated from "popping out" from axanthics.

We'll call that story #1

Then the other two following stories........

Story #2

WHITE-SIDED floridana HISTORY 12/8/09

posted by ~“Upscale”

The whitesided was originated from a single wild caught specimen found on September 17th, 1989. It was found under a fallen road sign in Deem City by Rubio Castro who was serving time and working along US Highway 27 picking up junk when Hurricane Hugo was two hundred miles from Florida and they were picking up loose debris in case it came towards Broward County. The snake was taken to the road crew supervisor, Matt Schenker because he liked snakes and was always checking the roadside while the crew were working. He didn’t know what he had, and brought it to a guy named Leo Dunbar who kept it for a month before selling it to the guy who started the line. The original was a male, and was bred to two female Brooks. One of those daughters was bred back to the father and the first whitesided and known hets were produced. The offspring were divided into two groups and sold to two different parties, unknown to each other that the other group existed. One guy was told they were from a wild caught het pair, and the other was told they were created from the witesided black rat, both lies, by the way. In addition, the original male and a single female were held back, also, without the investor’s knowledge. The original male died before breeding to the female, and the owner bred her to a Florida king male from the cane fields. That started a line that is not pure Brooks, but has been crossed with the other line and is wide spread as a part of the current whitesided line. They started out pure locality from south Florida until that pairing. Supposedly the line from the out crossed cane field crossing actually became a vigorous and bigger line. This breeder acquired a pair from one of the first investors as part of an agreement, and was able to jump start the project because the investor was not aware of the holdbacks. Within just a few years there were about six different people producing these snakes, and they just expanded like crazy and it seemed like all of a sudden everybody had them. Believe it or not, I admit it’s quite a story...

hybrid story #3

Quotes below directly from Rainer on the KS forum:

He didn’t know what he had, and brought it to a guy named Leo Dunbar who kept it for a month before selling it to the guy who started the line. The original was a male, and was bred to two female Brooks

1) This is where the story faulters. As you know I was indirectly involved with this line.
-----
www.Bluerosy.com

"I was indirectly involved with the making of the Florida x WS Blackrats" ~ Rainer Weishaupl

This is what i think gerard.

Some of the these snakes like the whitesided trait in Floridana has been bred back so many time that for all intense purposes, THEY ARE A FLROIDA KING. I mean that is what happene in the wild with hybrids. They just get absorbed back into the population. Don't think for a minute that a Florida king never bred to a ratsnake in florida. AND YOU WOULN'T BE ABLE TO TELL THEN EITHER.

I wish i neveR brought it up. Because people hear the word hybrid and just assume ..OH UNPURE! NASTY! COBRA FOOD !etc.
Which is not the case.

Lets talk about something else like nesting or bonding,, KKK!? LOL!

I always told the truth about the snakes. I was also not the one breed the WSmorph into the Floridana. I just found out that the persons who did (one passed away) and the other left the hobby (Tim Ricks)who lied to me and others. I prsonally had nothing to do with making the hybrids. I was just involved in a business transacation early on that the supposed founding stock which produced a ws brooks. Which ended up, was NOT the actual animals that produced the ws brooks. So that is is not where they cme from at all. Thats what got me into researching it. Then after speaking to serval people involved I was able to trace the history of the animals as well as George miskimmon who originated the ws blackrats. Sevral people were indirectly involed like I was. But had nothing to do with the breeding or coverup and falsly claiming these were the real deal.

It was all just detective work on my end.

Pat,
I was indirectly involved with the making of the Florida x WS Blackrats.

Now what I meant by "if you think about it", was that since I make my living off of Florida king morphs. Why would I make that up if it was to dirty the gene pool?

Also it is a long story. I have no idea where the links are. I am not that interested in broadcasting the history anyway.

So either take it or leave it. I don't care.

Gerard S. post:

It seems like the WW Speckled Kings would have been the best choice for him to use. They would have just made animals that already looked close. That does suck if that's the case.

Rainer’s very next response to Gerard:

Nope, they were ws blackrats.

Another response from Rainer to Pat regarding the WS:

Pat,
You alrady know this but. A lot of the old timers did breed hybrids back then and they passed them off as pure. nobdooy questioned them as it "was not an issue"...also because this was when people just started to learn the old receipe book for breeding. Bsiclly this hybrid subject was to new to even be considered in the realm of possibilty in most herpers minds.

And today those snakes are in the hands of purists who are the current "hybrid nazi's" of today.. it funny how life can nip you in the rear.lol , .

Just sayin, a lot of the origins of recessive traits came from hydridzing.

Original KS forum link to entire thread so anyone can try to sift through it to find the real answer through all the smoke and mirrors.

Starts Aug. 17, 2011

http://forums.kingsnake.com/forum.php?page=18&catid=75

So it's very simple.......someone is either lying about their story, or they just "think" they know how they originated and are very misinformed. There can only be one true story of how the very first WS originated. And it's pretty obvious what happened to at least some of them afterwards.

~Doug
-----
"a snake in the grass is a GOOD thing"

serpentinespecialties.webs.com

Nokturnel Tom Feb 27, 2013 11:05 AM

My version... is what I remember hearing from Tim Ricks... I did not read all that stuff you guys posted...
I do not do that any more.
The Specks I was directly involved in so I felt I should reply. I love the Brooksi/Floridana one too... history arguments... no
-----
TomsSnakes.com
twitter.com/TomsSnakes

brianm616 Feb 27, 2013 11:10 AM

doug, like i said - i wasn't interested about their genetics, or even backgrounds for that matter.

the point of this thread was to find out why there's such a huge price disparity between the two.

that is all.

if someone wants to start another thread about either of their histories, that will most likely degenerate, then they should.

thank you.

DMong Feb 27, 2013 11:33 AM

Well, I think the WW specks have a smaller niche and far less people breeding them because of their smaller hatchling size, food preferences with many initially, etc.. making them a bit more of a challenge and can take more patience and dedication as a whole.

They are great snakes for sure, and there is no question at all about their origin as Tom pointed out. They were 100% locale from 1985 Carter County Missouri stock. Since everyone breeds Florida kings and the origin is far less certain, that is very likely another big factor as to why they are more money too. Everything comes down to supply and demand as everyone knows.

~Doug
-----
"a snake in the grass is a GOOD thing"

serpentinespecialties.webs.com

brianm616 Feb 27, 2013 11:45 AM

that makes perfect sense. still, i wish they were cheaper
-----
i work with tri-colored west mexican lampropeltis. some morph, some hobby, and some locale.

everyone is entitled to their options, but no one's opinion will ever change how i feel about the snakes i keep and breed.

DMong Feb 27, 2013 11:46 AM

Yes, and of course the fact that the WS "Florida" kings were around long before the WW specks became available that was also pointed out. All of the above things are why their prices are so different.

~Doug
-----
"a snake in the grass is a GOOD thing"

serpentinespecialties.webs.com

Splitfire59 Feb 28, 2013 10:55 AM

Thanks for sharing Doug.
Alan,

DMong Feb 28, 2013 03:07 PM

Sure thing....

~Doug
-----
"a snake in the grass is a GOOD thing"

serpentinespecialties.webs.com

GerardS Feb 27, 2013 10:51 AM

I love the ww specks, theyre awesome. I have the probkem with the ws brooks and the way they were made. Great job on those specks, theyare bad as!
-----
Gerard

"How awesome would it be to deny the prophecy?"

www.livebaitclip.com

GONE FISHING!!!

MESOZOIC Feb 27, 2013 09:27 AM

>>history. the ww holbrooki have traceable history many of the first were locale specific of course once they hit the market many were and since been bred to holbrooki from many differant locales and im sure ssp. as well.
>>ive always felt the ws fla. were created from the ww speck but i do not know that to be true or if they are even combatable.
>>i will say its a cool mutation.
>>
>>,,,,,,,,thomas davis
>>-----
>>Morphs... just like baseball cards BUT ALIVE, how cool is that???
>>
>>my website www.barmollysplace.com

The WS Brooks were around way before the WS Specks came around.
-----
www.mesozoicreptiles.com

brianm616 Feb 27, 2013 11:16 AM

if that's the case, it would explain why the holbrooki are three fold more.

thanks.
-----
i work with tri-colored west mexican lampropeltis. some morph, some hobby, and some locale.

everyone is entitled to their options, but no one's opinion will ever change how i feel about the snakes i keep and breed.

GerardS Feb 27, 2013 12:01 PM

Rainer said they used the WS obsoleta to make the floridana. I think the specks are awesome snakes!
-----
Gerard

"How awesome would it be to deny the prophecy?"

www.livebaitclip.com

GONE FISHING!!!

Aaron Feb 27, 2013 09:52 PM

Yes Rainer made a pretty good case for the ws brooks being the result of crossbreeding ws black rats, ie body shape and head structure was supposedly off on the first generations.

At the very least the ws brooks are probably in reality ws floridana and not real brooks. My take has always been all brooks are floridana but not all floridana are brooks. Hence you can call any of them floridana but only brooks are brooks. Obviously the hobby at large does nto agree with me since basicly everything with a smidgen of real brooks in it is called a brooks nowadays.

If the ws brooks had come from verifiable locality specific brooks it probably would have been a big selling point at the time. I'm not a big brooks guy but I don't remember anyone making such claims.

I do however remember the ww speckleds being touted for their locality specific source.

The ws brooks have been around alot longer, hence much more common. Plus they have uncertain origins. Those two factors equal a much lower price than ww speckleds. As anything the ww speckleds will come down in time and get mixed with anything and everything but a small number of people will probably try to keep pure lines going despite lowered prices.
-----
www.hcu-tx.org/

GerardS Feb 27, 2013 10:01 PM

Yeah, real brooks are special animals.
-----
Gerard

"How awesome would it be to deny the prophecy?"

www.livebaitclip.com

GONE FISHING!!!

GerardS Feb 27, 2013 10:03 PM

Yeah, real brooks are special animals.
-----
Gerard

"How awesome would it be to deny the prophecy?"

www.livebaitclip.com

GONE FISHING!!!

Aaron Feb 28, 2013 02:20 AM

That they are my friend.
-----
www.hcu-tx.org/

thomas davis Feb 27, 2013 03:10 PM

>The WS Brooks were around way before the WS Specks came around.

yeah i know. about 5yrs before the specks were released the ws fla. were around.
my line came from tim ricks and ive never seen any obsaleta influence they look and act like trueblue getula.
my w/s fla. looked very much like trueblue floridana except the size maybe 4ft.tops, so who knows. id bet the farm the 2 are allelic though

,,,,,,,thomas davis
-----
Morphs... just like baseball cards BUT ALIVE, how cool is that???

my website www.barmollysplace.com

Site Tools