I can't answer about judges preferences or what have you, but people not in our breed comment so much on him because he is sound and has great ring presence. People just look at him and say.."WOW"!
Like him or not, must admit, it's pretty impressive that he got majority of his points and all of his majors towards championship in the groups, not the classes. And yes some of the shows might be small, but some of the tough competition goes there too.
To me a BIS is a BIS. Down the road, when people ask, who has the the record for most AKC All-breed BIS, they aren't going to say..Qing but he only beat xx amount of dogs in that show.
Earning one BIS is a great feat in our breed, earning multiples...outstanding!!! And all involved should be proud to brag, regardless of personal opinions.
-----
Bekki and
Atreyu AKA BIF FC DesertPhoenix Emerald Warrior, FCH,CGC,SC,RA,NA HIC, PHCA Versatility Excellent 2008
Bridget AKA ILP Kaije Staind Glass Beauty "Resident Cheerleader"
Uber aka AKC CH, UKC MBBIS CH XO Uber Alles, SC
La-La aka FC XO Ulala,SC 2010 PHCA Western Specialty Best of Winners