I have slowly read this entire thread (to date of my post here) and I have a few thoughts on this subject too. First of all, every person that has posted so far has very valid points and is correct in many of their views. No one person is entirely right and everyone else wrong,. it's more like a stew of a whole lot of correct points. But this post here really hits the nail on the head with this complex issue. It is SO true that it is entirely dependant upon the individual PERSON buying and keeping the snake,.. not so much what kind of snake he or she gets. My first snakes when I was 9 years old were rattlesnakes. I got my first boas when I was about 10 and my first burmese when I was about 11. This was back in the early 70's and not a lot of people knew much about reptiles in general and so as a result I was entirely self taught and learned primarily by trial and error. I made a lot of mistakes and as a result I lost basically all of my first snakes one way or another due to some form of ignorance on my part. But never once was the size of the snake any form of an issue with me. My first burmese reached over 11 feet within the first 2 or 3 years before I lost her due to a tragic mistake on my part. I was maybe 13 and very small for my age by the time she died. But her size was never an issue or a problem. At this same time I had other huge burmese, some really big retics and a couple of large rock pythons. Every retic and rock I had at that time were all imported snakes because no one was breeding them back then and so they were all HIGHLY aggressive snakes. As a result I quickly learned how to deal with them and even at a young age I had mastered how to handle them with an ease which resulted in almost never being bitten. I actually got nabbed much more frequently by the tame CB burmese and boas during feeding than by the aggressive pythons because my guard was generally down with the docile snakes. So in a sense the more aggressive the snakes I had, the more caution I exercised and as a result the safer I was overall. I even started handling and milking my rattlers by the time I was about 12 and I got quite good at it. During the 18 years I kept and handled hots (this ended in the 90's) I was never once bitten and only had what I would consider to be 3 close calls. The overall point being,. I was young when I started all of this with venomous reptiles and giant species of pythons, but I was serious about learning and doing it right and I think I did rather well with it. I had a few other friends that did similar things while at young ages.
Also,. I personally DO think that a young person or novice reptile enthusiest can acquire a juvenile retic or other large python species as a first snake, and "grow with it". In most cases it takes the retic or burm 4 or 5 years before it is of a considerable size and in that time a young teen would certainly have grown up. And most certainly a "newbie" would undoubtedly learn about the snake just during the first few months of keeping it and as it grows would undoubtedly learn how to cope with its ever increasing size. At Bob Clark's facility I personally dragged Fluffy around by myself from outside on the lawn to the facility and through all three buildings to her cage. I broke a sweat, but I managed to pull her 300 pounds and 24 feet, all by myself, without too much difficulty. And I am not a power lifting kind of guy.
So yes, I do think it comes down to the individual more than just a 'cookie cutter' type "ideal starter snake" for the ideal conditions in herp keeping beginnings.
Rott made some good points about it being expensive to keep large snakes. While this is true if one purchases their snake food from a pet shop or expensive rodent breeder, it is not the only way to get food. If one raises one's own food it can not only be cheap and easy, but it can be FREE if one sells surplus food to other reptile keepers to generate monies to pay for rat and rabbit food. Or, like in my case, it can not only be free, but it can also MAKE you money to breed and sell your own food. As I sell my food items very cheaply it is a win win for everyone involved. I get my free food, make a couple grand extra, and my friends save a fortune not having to order expensive frozen food.
Sorry for the long post. Very complex issue. Hard to sum up. I'm glad someone brought it up though. Things have been very dull in the forums lately. It's nice to have something slightly controvesial and intellectually stimulating for a refreshing change.
>>I don't think this is something that can be solved. It's more of a person to person thing.
>>
>>
>>Some people could buy a Retic/Burm/Green Anaconda/Any other large snake as their first and be awesome keepers. Others can start with a Corn and work up to a Retic and still be horrible keepers.
-----
"If I had 365 enemies it would only take a year out of my life to settle all scores." Mia Miselfani