Hi Rick,
Several years for a larval tiger to transform is far from the norm, with most transforming well before that. I still think the salamander is too young to be gravid.
Also, I think it should be mentioned use of hormones is not always in the animals best interests, and you could lose your pet. It's quite the gamble.
By captive laying I assume you mean a gravid female is wild collected and then lays while in captivity? From her post she said she had both of hers together since morphing and it has just recently grown in size leading her to suspect she was gravid, so I suspect it was not a recently wild collected animal.
Also you speak about breeding tiger salamanders naturally. As I mentioned, to date no one has ever successfully bred tiger salamanders in captivite conditions without hormones. Are you speaking from suspected methods that could promote breeding, or have you or someone you know had success with the breeding? If you or someone you know has, I would be eager to hear all the details and see the photos of this event, and I suggest you share it on www.caudata.org with the other enthusiasts, as it would be a large step foward for captive breedings of Ambystoma species.
I currently am establishing an Ambystoma breeding project, so even if you're speaking from suspected methods I would be interested if you contacted me and we could talk about these methods and why they are suspected.
>>It can take three or more years for a tiger salamander to transform. and can breed the first season that they do. It is possible that your salamander is gravid, however captive laying with out the use of hormones is rare, but has happened. The reason for this is that the females will not lay their eggs Unless a body of still water at least 18 inches deep and of suffcient size is available. I know this from observation of wild breeding sites. Tigers salamanders will not lay eggs in smaller bodies of water and if there has not been suffcient rain fall to produce bodies of water that size they will not breed at all. Most keepers will inject their salamander with hormones to induce egg laying at this point. You can get LH-RH without a perscription from a chemical laboratory for this purpose. If you wanted to breed them naturally then your best bet is to setup an indoor pond or aquarium with suitable land area and at least 75 gallons of still water 18 to 24 inches deep as a minimum.
-----
Hope my opinions help,
Rob