Reptile & Amphibian Forums

Welcome to kingsnake.com's message board system. Here you may share and discuss information with others about your favorite reptile and amphibian related topics such as care and feeding, caging requirements, permits and licenses, and more. Launched in 1997, the kingsnake.com message board system is one of the oldest and largest systems on the internet.

Click here for Dragon Serpents
Click for ZooMed
Click here for Dragon Serpents

Does anyone else notice how much we change substrates?...

-ryan- Dec 01, 2003 03:24 PM

I myself have tried 6 different substrates so far. When i got sidney, the tank had a combination of calcium sand and bark chips (I know, I just didn't know what I was doing). When I realized who dangerous that was, especially since that was when I was feeding him crickets in his tank, I went out and bought some rabbit pellets and tried them out. They looked un natural, and the whole upstairs smelled like petshop, not to mention my allergies were killing me. So then I was going to buy repti carpet, but instead I got about $60 worth of zoo med's reptisand. My vet advised me against using sand, so I put sidney on repticarpet. Then sidney had coccidia, so I had him on paper towels over the summer. Then back to repticarpet, and now playsand. Now I'm thinking about making another switch...shelf liner. But I was thinking, have any of us actually ever had an impaction problem with adult beardeds on sand? If you're not feeding him/her in their tank? From all that I've read and seen, most big commercial breeders use some sort of sand, and most have never had a problem. I still might put him on shelf liner though, just because i like to try out all my options, and he's going to need a substrate switch soon anyways (by january I think). By the way, is "caribean playsand" the stuff I'm supposed to use, or is there a different kind of sand?

I was just thinking about all the different substrates people use. I remember about a year ago the big thing was bran. Everyone was trying it out. Of course, bran had disadvantages. Now it seems like everyone's doing the shelf liner thing (which is much better than bran because it's more sanitary). What do you think will be next?

Replies (4)

BigFil Dec 01, 2003 03:50 PM

The way I see the whole impaction sand thing is this, and it is only my opinion and reasoning. Yes, it can and does happen occasionally, but for as many people that probably keep their BD's on playsand I would say the chances are low. It is possible to walk down the street and trip on one of those sidewalk cracks and die, and it probably has happened from time to time, but walking down the sidewalk is still for the most part considered safe for most people. You could definately choose to not walk on sidewalks and make the chances of you dieing that way zero. There are risks with everything in life you just need to decide for your self what an acceptable risk level for you. If you want to eliminate any slight possiblities, than by all means don't use sand it's an informed choice you need to make for yourself.

Jim Lacey Dec 01, 2003 05:25 PM

I agree completely with BigFil, and just to let you know I have had Pepe on washed playsand now for over 2 years without any roblems.
Pepe's Home Page

ortred Dec 01, 2003 06:32 PM

np

Christyj Dec 01, 2003 07:16 PM

First, let me say I am in no way arguing...

I think it depends highly on the beardie itself. Obviously, if some get impacted there is something different happening.
Maybe they go after the crix with too much gusto and get a bit of sand everytime they eat a cricket (that would be a lot over time). Maybe some are just lickers.

I used to use sand and was pretty happy with it. When Daisy got coccidia/hookworm, I took it out. After thinking about it a bit (and cleaning the sand out), I can see how it may not be the most sanitary thing. Even when you scoop poop, some liquid goes to the bottom through the sand and stays there. Sometimes the sand is wet with liquid, then just dries when you've gotten the big poop out. Most people let the sand stay in for several months before they change it out. That's alot of icky stuff over time.

I have nothing against sand, I used it for several yrs. I just really like the shelf liner. I think cleanliness plays a huge part in beardie health. I can't think of one bad thing to say about it.
You can disinfect it with ease.
It never smells
It looks great
A damp cloth cleans it all up.
Nothing sinks to the bottom.
You can get colors (lol)
-----
TheClassyLizard

Site Tools