I wouldn't go with peromyscus, and every single strain of mice that produces big healthy litters, are of necessity big healthy mice! Smaller mice don't have the physical inside space to have large litters. As was mentioned you are out of luck as far as finding a small mouse with large litters. Peromyscus has tiny litters, and is tiny, swiss websters have large litters and are large bodied. One person mentioned rats... Since I have found a source who wishes to purchase my excess rats at a very very profitable margin for myself, I have been slowly increasing the number of rat colonies I have. The newborn pinks are good for my larger '03 hatchlings, The fuzzies are great for my yearling colubrids, the hoppers are great for my younger ball pythons, and the young adults are good for the bigger balls. When they reach full adult size they are worth more to me sold to someone else than used as feeders for my animals. And they grow just as fast as mice, which means they get huge quickly. More food bang for the buck... so to speak.
-----
~Sasheena