Hmmmmmmm, how does one explain it and drop names to make it right, all at the same time.
First let me ask you some questions,
Do you really think a litebulb is the sun? do you think the monitors really think so? Exactly what in those papers from those fine authors caused or led them to say what they said??
Once a really great herper and keeper, Erine Wagner, came over and upon viewing my outdoor cages. He asked about the lites that were on at night. He asked, what about the photoperiod? I looked to the sky and said, in the mourning, the sun will come up over there. That is a lite bulb.
While that seems very basic and simple minded, it is. The sun is the sun and a lite bulb is a lite bulb. There is a bit more to how reptiles respond to the sun, then only from the lite. Like when they are deep down in burrows, how do they know its day?
About lites and captivity, If your going to use a litebulb as a heat source, 24/7, you really should allow the monitors to be able to excape the lite and find dark areas, like burrows etc. WAIT, shouldn't you allow that anyway?
Dr. Ube Krebs gave a talk on the effects of varying photoperiods on Ackie reproduction. I attended, the result, it did not have an effect. I agreed.
I do have a little experience with ackies, and many other species. In fact, generation after generation of experience. I have successfully kept them and bred them, with lites on 24/7, with a lite cycle, with a lite cycle that resembled the one here, and the ones where they originated. And now experimenting with no added lite. The result is again the same, as long as they have access to proper temps and other non-lite related husbandry, they do great.
More questions, I have for you, do you really think monitors or any reptiles comes out with the sun comes up, and stays out until is down? ever?
In all reality, reptiles become active and inactive for the same reasons in both captivity and nature, they do so because its allowable and benefitual. Heat is more of an attraction and a deterent then lite.
More reality, many individual monitors with 24/7 lites, choose to become active in our night. The reason, they do not like us. Or to avoid other cagemates. This is so, even with apparently tame monitors. hmmmmmmmm. FR