Hey everyone. I just read a few of the arguments about soil, 24/7 lighting etc down below and wanted to say a couple comments. First of all all the potential problems that have bene brought up are completely valid. There could definitely be potential problems with diggable dirt substrate and a 24/7 lighting system. These methods of husbandry have not been tested adequately (at least I don't think) in Bearded Dragons.
But that does bring up another point. All of the ways we have learned to care for dragons had to start somewhere. I'm sure there have been times in the past when a simple husbandry choice that has now become accepted and common knowledge (ie "hey, they don't really need a waterbowl"
was looked down upon. It is only through trying new things that we may learn even better methods to care for our dragons. Personally, I care for my dragons too much to put them in an environment that I am unsure about its safety but I think there is a place for testing new methods of husbandry.
The only problem with this is when people bring up a new possible method for keeping dragons and relatively new keepers attempt a fairly difficult method of keeping their lizards. I know this happened on the Uromastyx forum just a few months ago. The idea of a dirt substrate was introduced by a very advanced lizard keeper. For this person, I honestly believe dirt substrate was the way to go, as Uromastyx are definitely burrowing lizards and the person had a tremendous prior knowledge of dirt substrates. But even then, the method had not been tested adequately (and I'm looking forward to seeing the results next year). But all of a sudden, a huge number of people read the posts and decided to try a very complicated system. Anyway, I felt a lot of people jumped the gun (including myself for one of my uromastyx, although he is doing quite well on dirt) without taking into consideration that the method had not been tested with this species of lizard.
My point among all this rambling is I do think new methods of husbandry have a place and we should not attack anyone who decides to try something new. But beginning keepers should be advised to stick to what has been proven to be healthy to a vast number of animals before trying a novel approach.
Peter





