Funny thing. My opinion is just the opposite.
I hate dimmer switches. Yea, they work and are a little cheaper. By far your best bet is a proportional thermostat. But in place of that, an on/off thermostat will adjust to the ambient room temps.
For example, what happens if your at work/school/whatever, and your air conditioner quits working. Well, the dimmer hasn't a clue. And doesn't really care about the temp of the tub. So it just keeps applying electricity to the heat tape and in some cases could cause an over heating. Or a fire. Since the dimmer or rheo doesn't have a probe to sample the temps, it just keeps on going. Same if it suddenly got to cold in the room. It's doesn't kick in and warm things to fix that either. So if it's winter and your dimmer is set to a medium setting and your furnace quits, it won't warm up to offset the cold temps.
At least a on/off thermostat will. I have proportionals on my main racks. But all my hatchling racks, holding racks, etc. have simple on/off thermos. And they rarely fluctuate 1/2 a degree. Even in the midwest where now, our outside temps go from one extreme to another every other day. Again, just my opinion.
Troy Dozier
Reptilian Projects