and they are very valid. But as you stated, I knew unsavory breeders who knew their way around the system, making it a mockery. Even with the blood tests and such, it is still very much an honor system (the AKC). The problem being is they really have a monopoly. So, prices went up yearly and more fees were being added. If your dog sires more than 7 litters...more fees....Why? Because they could do it. There was no competition. Do we want to end up being charged for breeding boas as well (not just a yearly license)? You may think it is out of the realm of possiblity, but it is not. Organizations are human, they become very gluttonous.
With this forum, if you don't like the rules there are other alternative forums (granted not as far reaching yet, but the option is there)...with the registry, there is no other American alternative. On the other hand, I've had friends messed over by the registry, when it should not have happened. Don't get me wrong, so long as I was breeding and showing dogs I used the registry...I had to or I couldn't show. I, personally have had no real problems with them, and for as long as I own pure bred dogs, I hope I don't. I am just trying to show alternative points. Will the benefits out weight the hardships? Maybe, I can't deny there will be benefits.
But, as far as a boa registry, the sad point would be that even if it were optional, those who did register their livestock would start slamming the breeding of those who did not. Maybe not everyone and maybe not viciously, but the seed of doubt would be planted...It would become a status symbol, and those that didn't register would end up being ostracized. By this I mean the "little guy" or little hobbyist (even if they have nothing to hide), whose pockets do not reach so deep as the big guys. And there would be much money to be made by he/she who would start such a registry, so, to keep fairness in mind, if there were a board for this registry, have it include a few "little guys" as well, for all decisions should not be made by the rich (who can afford any fees imposed) alone.
Perhaps there should be pure locality registry, I'm not saying there shouldn't be...so long as we can maintain control of it rather than it controlling us. We do not always like to reap the seeds we sow...I just want it to be a thoroughly thought out decision, with keeping the future of what the registry may become in mind.
-----
