I feed my kids a combo of minnows, earthworms (cut to a size appropriate for the snake), and frozen thawed pinkies or fuzzies. Some of them took to the worms and mice with no problem. My ribbons have been reluctant to take anything but minnows, so I put the pinks and worms in the dish with the minnows and they just grab whatever they hit and swallow it down. Yot can also rub the minnows on the worms or mice to mask the scent, and this will also sometimes trick them. Once they try a worm or two, mine have always prefered them to the minnows. I can understand being reluctant to feed rodents if you keep them as pets, I have rats of my own, but if you get them already frozen and remember that these are food and your others are pets, it gets easier. Mice are a very nutitious part of a captive garters diet, and they are easy to come by. I still like to feed a variety, as I think they "enjoy" the different textures and smells. They also like to chase those little fish in the bowl. Good luck!
-----
Debbie
My email