This type of discussion always amazes me 
Placing live animals in a bag until they suffocate is illegal.
'Stunning' live rats or mice by smacking their heads into hard objects (truck bumpers, tables,walls, the floor) is - you guessed it - illegal.
That is why we have animal cruelty laws in every state - to prevent people from doing those very things. . .
Cervical dislocation is appropriate (after being trained by a pro, BTW) only for smaller mice and rats - *never* large rats (they have necks like buffalo - built).
I know the topic is confusing, but the AVMA kindly provided guidelines on euthanasia years ago:
http://www.mc.uky.edu/dlar/links/avmaeuth.htm
Pretty simple stuff, and for most people CO2 is the best choice.
All the pros I know use frozen rodents anyway, purchased from a reputable supplier. Or Snake Sausages (made with poultry, BTW - not ground up rodents).
Don't go around whacking rats on the head, or stuffing them into ziplocs, or drowning, stomping, pithing, or freezing them alive (always a favourite). If you are confused, ask a professional, like your vet. . .
Norvvy