>people other than breeders keep these animals sucessfully >without harm to anything?
A very good question, and one that I haven't quite made up my mind on. But here's how my thinking is going so far-
Assuming a stable market demand for Corucia, and limited production capacity for CB animals: Every WC or CB animal that is bred results in one less animal being removed from the wild. Every animal that is not bred doesn't reduce demand for WC animals. So every un-bred animal is a wasted resource. Why is this different for Corucia than for, say, a green iguana? Currently CB "production" of iguanas exceeds demand. This is apparent when you look at the numbers of iguanas that end up in rescues or being sold at very low prices. Since CB production is higher than demand it has virtually eliminated the demand for more expensive, less healthy WC iguanas. Not breeding an iguana is actually a service, as it reduces the supply - resulting in fewer green iguanas on the market (and in rescues or discarded into the wild). The demand for Corucia far outstrips current CB "production" capacity (we'll leave alone for the moment whether it also exceeds WC production capacity ). Not breeding captive Corucia effectively removes that animal *and all potential offspring* from the market. If that animal had been bred you would have increased CB supply, and reduced WC demand.
> but i dont believe that monkey tails are endangered.
I'm curious about this one. Granted, the research hasn't yet been done to conclusively prove one way or the other what is truly going on with wild Corucia populations, but the evidence points strongly to declining populations. Why is it you believe they aren't at risk? (Please don't take this question as an attack, I am genuinely curious.)
>There are many places that breed these animals, for pets and >other wise.
I've been able to find very few breeders. Do you know of some? I personally know 3 private individuals who breed these animals or are attempting to breed them. I know of at least 2 others on this group who breed them. I don't think any of these 5 people regularly (ever?) sell their animals. I also suspect that Walkabout Farms is breeding them, but again, I'm not sure that they sell them. Most that I see available for sale are from private individuals who don't appear to be breeding in large numbers (or they would have more frequent ads), people selling older pairs, or importers.
> I think that experienced hobbiests should have the right to >keep them with out any major issues.
I agree with you here. You do have the right to keep whatever animal is legal to keep in your city/state/country. However, I believe that you owe it to the animals that you keep and to the other humans that share this planet with you to know the ecological implications of your actions and to give serious thought to the moral issues involved. The fact that you're here having this discussion tells me that you agree with at least part of my last statement, which is IMO a Good Thing, and I commend you.
>I mean honestly, what if nobody ever kept an exotic animal >because they couldnt breed them. There would be no market for >crested geckoes, and no red ackies being bred in captivity at >all...except for maybe in zoos.
This goes once again to the question of how the supply of CB animals matches up to the demand for animals. If it exceeds the demand there is no problem with not breeding your individual animal. If it doesn't, perhaps it isn't a good pet to keep without the intention of breeding.
Looked at from another perspective- if no one bred their pet ackies or crested geckos the only ones you could buy would be WC, or none at all once wild populations were gone.
I look forward to hearing others thoughts on this question.
-Z