Hey Rob,
I am the one who gave the "bad" advice. It can be tough to maintain perfect conditions in many cages due to the cage design and room conditions. It can be difficult , if not impossible to create sufficient humidity levels in a cage with large amounts of ventilation, especially when they are placed in the top of the cage due to low humidity levels in the room where the cage is kept. Since higher humidity levels will create a higher vapor pressure in a airspace, any ventilation will allow that air to equalize with the cooler drier room air. Placing any vents on top of a cage will also create a "chimney effect" as any warm air in the cage rises, which will cause the air in the cage to quickly be replaced with cooler, drier, room air. Most overhead incandecent heat sources need to be placed outside the cage to avoid a burn hazard, and a screen opening installed in the top of the cage. These heat sources can create large updrafts, increasing this air transfer significantly, quickly "sucking" both the heat and humidity out of the cage.
Although I absolutely agree with you that ventilation is a great thing, ambient conditions in many locations where animals are kept are far from optimum and one must make some allowances. Low temperatures and low humidity levels will also stress a reptile, which can lead to RI infections as well as lowering the animals overall resistance to other problems.
The only way to maintain adequate humidity levels in these situations is to limit the amount of ventilation, especially in the top portions of a cage. I have found and I know 100s of people who also need to limit the ventilation in order to create the proper conditions, especially during the winter in much of the country, and the summer in locations where one is running an air conditioner, resulting in lower room humidity. I do tell people that most times, any vents in the top of the cage are counterproductive and that any vents should be installed lower in the cage and one should be able to adjust/close them when the room conditions are less than optimum. I have also found that often, the gap between the front glass, along with periodic opening of the cage is sufficient air exchange which will allow the cage to maintain better humidity levels. I also state that if mold or mildew does form, obviously there is a problem with excess moisture that has to be addressed. It may be that a condition such as the water bowl being regulary spilled is creating excessive moisture at that location, soaking a substrate which will then allow the formation of mold, which would not necessarily be a result of excessive humidity in the entire cage.
The cage may also be overmisted, which can cause such a problem. All of this must be taken into account and the cage and husbandry procedures adjusted accordingly.
The other problem can be with the hygrometer being used, or where it is placed in the cage. Many of the cheaper units sold are worthless as they quickly go out of calibration. I have tested some units that read "desert" levels when in fact the cage had a 85% relative humidity.
Since conditions will vary greatly from one location to another, I do not feel that a blanket rule can apply.
Bob @ Pro Products
Pro Products