Hello, I went in to pick up supplies at my local store and happened upon a tank marked "assorted toads". I tt the manager and she said she ordered a specific type of toad (she didn't remember what kind) but instead, they shipped her a container marked "assorted" so she wasn't really sure what they were. One of the girls there had a suspicion on a couple of them, and in looking at online photos I think she is right. I don't want to say what she thought and taint your own opinions. I was assured that none of them were American Toads. I have an American Toad and they do not look like him, so I was at least able to rule that out. I'll post some photos and if you could share with me your thoughts that would be great. I'll keep searching Toad sites on my own too in hopes of figuring it out.
Toad #1 top view

Toad #2 top view

Toad #3 top view

Toad #4 top view

For the following photos they were only flipped (or held) long enough to take the photo and then immediately put right side up again. Now that I have the photos I'll never flip them like that again. Just thought their bellies and feet might help with the ID to find out what they are so I'm sure I'm caring properly for them.
Toad #1 bottom view

Toad #2 bottom view

Toad #3 bottom view

Toad #4 bottom view

The following shots are just to show you their size. I do not normally play with or handle them.
Toad #1 for size comparison, this one is the largest one

Toad #2 for size comparison

Toad #3 for size comparison

Toad #4 for size comparison This one is much smaller than the others and has shorter legs

-----
Lyns Lair
WNY Herpetological Society
0.1 Cat (Mia)
4.2 Ferrets (Wolf, Shadow, Verdell, Sullivan, Boo, Peach)
8.0 Rats (Inky, Oy, Ben, Pinky, Templeton, Cotton, Bilbo, Carlo)
1.0 Carpet Python (Bear)
1.0 Malagasy Blonde Hognose (Wilbur)
1.0 Yellow/Everglades Rat Snake (Pumpkin)
1.0 Russian Sand Boa (Fang)
0.1 California King Snake (Boo)
0.1 Normal Corn Snake (Mysty)
1.0 Anery Corn Snake (Suezo)
1.1 Normal Corn Snakes het Pewter and Snow (Romeo & Juliet)
2.1.1 Eastern Milk Snakes (Uno, Dos, Tres, Snoopy)
1.0 Ball Python (Slytherin)
2.0 Smooth Green Snakes (Fred & George)
1.0 Northern Water Snake (coming soon)
0.1 Golden Greek Tortoise (Sunshine)
0.2 Mississippi Mud Turtles (Squirt & Shyanne)
1.0 Green Iguana (Norbert)
1.0 Bearded Dragon (Moose)
0.0.1 Mountain Horned Dragon (Tiramisu)
1.0 American Toad (Bump)
1.0 AFT Gecko (Cocoa)
5.5 Leopard Geckos (Trouble, Scooter, Simba, Firenze, Teddy, Mystique, Freckles, Dotty, Zipper, Twister)


