I have seen many bits and pieces of factual and inaccurate information on this thread. I am not new to this hobby, but have been out of Uroplatus for almost two years. I am going to be conducting research on this genus, and I am sure many of you will get an e-mail with the chance to contribute. I have bred almost every species among the Genus. The majority of the information can be summed up as, " U. malahelo, and U. alluadi have never been kept in captivity outside of Madagascar. U. malama has been kept in Europe and the United States years ago, but rumors have been spread of a few Europeans and Japanese hobbyists keeping them currently(Not from current imports.), and U. guntheri is being bred in Japan, Europe, Canada, and the United States. In Europe U. guntheri are more readily available than in the United States and Canada. Numbers in the United States are low, and the price and demand is high. They haven't been imported in three year and most likely won't be, because their locality is remote and traveling their is more money than it's worth for collectors to collect them.
U. malahelo was found while its habitat was being destroyed and most likely is extinct or the population is extemely Endangered. Deforestation is such an issue, which impacts all species and undiscovered species and sub-species. U. alluadi is known from on a single or few specimens and current status is unknown.
U.malama is larger than U.phantasticus by about 5mm, differing structure and scalation. The facts on whether this species has been imported in recent shipments over the few years. The chances ares slim.
The quotas might have a number for each species, but like U. guntheri the locality of each species is different. So, because of localities, it makes collecting difficult.
Below is a picture of one of my gravid U.lineatus a few years ago.

Geckos By Brad