I've never run into the problem of tort's not eating because of the supplements, however I can imagine some pickier guys may turn there noses at it.
I wanted to add that when choosing a calcium supplement, choose one Without Vitamin D added. Why? Well, when to much calcium is supplemented, any excess will pass through in the feces. Unless there is enough Vitamin D3 available to absorb all of the Calcium, in which excesses will cause problems when deposited around the body.
If you use natural sunlight / proper bulbs then you never have to worry about over supplementation of calcium because the tortoise can regulate the Vitamin D and calcium absorption.
I know it doesn't answer you question, but thought it may interest you 