>>I'm not really sure why I am debating this issue. Both ways will work fine, but if you want better success in the long run, I suggest you use an incubator. There is no way you can tell me that letting a female coil around eggs and try to keep a constant temp for 2 months is best for the animal or eggs. NO F"en WAY!!!!!!
I don't know why you are debating the issue either, if the tubs temps are kept constant than the female isn't working all that hard now is she?
>> I'll bet that if you did it both ways that the eggs that were incubated would produce bigger babies. Ask any women out there, and if they are telling you the truth, they will tell you...BIGGER IS BETTER. Lol
Uh no - bigger is not better, bigger babies are not only much more difficult to push out, but they are also more prone to diabetes. Take this from a woman that has had three and comes from a nice big Irish Catholic family of 12!
>> I will let all you "experts" out there do what you want. I haven't touched my incubators in days. How much have you been messing with your females that have been maternally incubating? Lol. I'll also be sure to tell Bob Clark, Mike Wilbanks,Pete Kahl, Ralph Davis,etc. etc.. etc.. that they might not be doing what's best. I read it on the forum after all. Lol
It's all a control issue. Not what's better, you just contridicted your first statement saying both work fine.
LOL it's not worth debating peopel have their reasons for breeding and incubating, leave it be, it's no "better" to maternally or atrifically incubate.
-----
Tosha 
8.15.0 Ball Python (Harry and Fluffy and currently un-named)
1.0.0 Angolan Python
0.2.0 Feline (Pippen and Pandora)
0.0.1 Dessert Tortoise (Pope)
2.2.1 Fish (1,2,3,4)
0.0.3 Lizards rescued from pool skimmer