I agree 100% with everything you’ve said here… I’d always take quality vet care as first choice, I don’t think there’s any possibility of arguing that at all…
I think the crux of the issue is in the question of how experienced an owner needs to be, and how accessible the treatment regimens are…and you make a very good point about having the close support of a really good vet, not just well-intentioned internet advice…
I think the discussion really concerns where along the scale from novice pet-owner to fully accredited DVM is right to try to diagnose and treat a pet…balanced against the scale of availability of outside vet care and the practical hurdles there are to using it.
My stance is that moving the critical meeting points of these curves towards it being easier for less experienced keepers to treat their herps will save herp lives and ease suffering.
One end of the spectrum is professional animal keepers: for example a dairy farmer: de-worming, oral antibiotics, vaccinations, treatment of superficial injuries, calving, many other veterinary tasks…all handled in house… I think they would fall well into the category of experienced, well researched and closely vet supported.
I think many experienced animal breeders from dogs and cats to corn snakes or geckos would also be along that end of the spectrum of qualified care givers…
Another idea is that of experienced keepers of traditional domestic pets- if my 0.3 felinus behaviorus terribilus get ear mites I don’t need to pay 3 vet visit fees to diagnose the situation… or treat it…
With mammals deworming or treating infected eyes, superficial cuts (can you tell I favor adopting from shelters?)…heartworm and flea medicines- these are all well-understood situations with easy to use medicines…
When you cross over into cold-blooded critters there are more complex considerations…it's much harder to diagnose and especially administer without stressing and harming the animal...
Take Japanese Koi… until very recently there has been zero veterinary care available for fish… now it is primarily only at research veterinary colleges.
For years koi keepers have relied on each other both for information and in hierarchies of expertise and equipment. Koi keepers share this information fully, from simple tips every pond-keeper can do to improve their water, to surgical removal of tumors in your garage… each keeper does what they are are comfortable with and relies on more experienced fellow enthusiasts if care is required beyond their abilities…
There are 2 or 3 guys in the regional koi club who have good scopes and are confident in IDing microfauna and comfortable anaesthetizing and injecting fish. There simply is no real koi vet in existence.
So the individual mostly diagnoses and treats their own animals- there really are a limited number of treatable conditions, and a limited number of treatments, most pertaining to infections or parasitizations, almost always secondary to poor water conditions.
See the attached photo of a fish from my pond- it was speared through the shoulder flesh, ripped out the gills and exited the gill plate- very serious injury! A combination of antibiotic-laced food, liberal application of Neosporin to the wound, and repeated mild potassium permanganate baths as disinfectant, pulled this fish through and it returned to full activity with very little scarring.
The downside is that some folks go haywire- folks forget that microbes are always with us, purchase megawatt UV sterilizer units to try to eliminate all micro-organisms form the water, perform drastic regular prophylactic permanganate treatments, obsessively scope slime scrapings, purchase multi-thousand dollar filter systems… and some fish get killed when guys miscalculate, multiply metric x English like NASA and overdose their pond by a factor of a thousand.
But in the end many more fish are saved and live healthier lives because the owners are educated in what treatments are available and can apply them themselves.
Now applying this experience to herps- I agree encouraging vet care should be apart of the advice for any sick herp- but wouldn’t our forums be a better place if that was done politely and encouragingly, as a matter of leadership toward better care, with self-help options as well as outside treatment, especially without bullying?
In reality there are many animals out there in the same boat as the koi- for whatever reasons there is not going to be vet care for them (I think a frank discussion of what the real hurdles are, and how to overcome them, is a good one and deserves its own thread…another night) … and like for koi the more information and accessibility to treatment of the commonest and most easily treated illnesses the more herps will survive.
This is a matter both of information and developing techniques for administering medications. As with fish, for herps there really are a limited number of common maladies, shouldn’t we be able to diagnose and treat them ourselves if we want to? Most top koi sites sell antibiotic food pellets, for example…very easy to dose. I’ve considered the merits of putting a dosage of those pellets inside a f/t mouse, LOL!!! But I haven’t done so…
There will be “casualties” with self-treatment but in net, way more herps will live than are harmed…and As I pointed out, the reduction in disease transmittal would be enormous…
With my experience in koi-tending I find it frustrating that there isn’t more practical discussion about home treatment, not to lead people away form vet care, but to give everyone more options.
