I'm not saying I support it, I just wanna hear some different opinions and make this a real debate! heeheehee
Well, given the number of DOR on some days within a small stretch of road in a particular area, I can't understand why they haven't been extirpated already!
Speaking hypothetically: if I'm driving along and encounter a turtle in the road, one of three things may happen: I inadvertently run over it (didn't see it until too late), I run over it on purpose (I've seen people do it--AS I'M STEPPING OUT OF MY CAR TO PICK IT UP), or I swerve out of the way successfully. Now, repeat this process times 10 or even 100 to account for every car passing the turtle as it makes its way across the road. The odds are definitely not in favor of the turtle's survival.
Why do I bring this up? Regardless of whether the turtle is picked up and brought home or run over, it is equally "dead" to the locality's breeding population from a genetic standpoint. Therefore, though I have qualms about wild-caught, I have less qualms about road-caught.
That is to say, a chance encounter with a turtle on a road resulting in potentially saving the individual turtle's life (though not helping the local population) is more acceptable to me than collecting a couple dozen turtles with the aid of a trained "sniffer" dog. Make sense?
-----
Chris McMartin
www.mcmartinville.com
I'm Not a Herpetologist, but I Play One on the Internet