....Ya mite wana cut n paste this to a larger font...cuz its a long post....
This is always a recycled...theme....but a good one..cuz it forces herpers to take sides! Im hugely in the permit or prohibit side...cuz I've seen & had to mop up behind...any number of nutcases possessing hot snakes. I really like the idea of a bond posting/insurance or meaningful permit system like Fl to weed out the most egregious....Ck out the cobra story appended below....incredible that society tolerates that possibility...as we vote for those who promise....& then deliver...more laws.... for our total security!
Anyway this is what it went like last time....the first coupla rants are mine...
Posted by regalringneck on July 27, 2001 at 07:32:24:
In Reply to: Re: A Call to Arms ...ok Ill bite the bait.... posted by regalringneck on July 26, 2001 at 21:47:37:
What a chump I am! Here I thought logic mattered to others too! All you need is a healthy fixation on what self wants & just go4it muttering about freedom. I hope (hope springs eternal...) that any Natl. Council will be comprosed of more rational individuals than has been seen thus far here. Hint guys: There is no logical analogy nor metaphor that connects traffic/guns/drugs/dogs etc. to the logical outcome of a taipan cruising the neighborhoods of our cities. I've maintained lots of hots & more than once been distracted away from an open cage to come back & have to find & catch the nasty...Do it enough, it'll happen to you. When your hand is as scarred as mine, we can talk about what might constitute appropriate ammends for an unfortunate innocent.
Contrary to current thought...It aint "all about me"!
cheers & beers, john gunn
: Pray tell, will someone explain the logic that permits many to think it is ok for anyone (& everyone) to keep a venomous snake in an urban environment (unfettered by govt regulation or permitting process)? The 2nd ammendment mebbe (I know...you can have my mamba when you pry my cold dead....blah blah blah)? Does the same logic allow me to keep my favorite....virus...ebola? Well why not?
: Im here to tell you if my sweet Sarah wound up losing her arm (or life) from making the simple mistake of picking up a simple brown snake running loose in the neighborhood....the owner had better pray the govt. gets to them before we have our private meeting of the minds & "closure"!
: Keepers of hots need to stand or fall on the merits (or lack thereof) of their argument, & not try to become cryptic by mingling their wants w/ the privledges our society currently affords keepers of harmless herps.
: I still shudder to think about one nutcase I shut down w/ a dump of a backyard filled with torn cardboard boxes full of snattlerakes (113 )....he was going to start a venom ranch! The neighbors finally got sick of the AWOL buzztails....Folks you have to understand the median IQ out there is scary!
: None of this is meant to minimize the need for a National Council that argues our interest mind you.
: OK; standing by for incoming.....
Posted by Marty on July 27, 2001 at 12:18:55:
In Reply to: Re: A Call to Kevin et al...I see my error now... posted by regalringneck on July 27, 2001 at 07:32:24:
"What a chump I am! Here I thought logic mattered to others too!"
I guess you are a chump because you are wanting to impose what you consider "logic" on others. So what you said at the end of your post, "It aint all about me!," actually, seems to be untrue. It is about you and the way you think things should be. Just because you don't think it is wise for people to be able to keep hots "in the city" just means that you are like the rest of us - you have an opinion on a subject.
"All you need is a healthy fixation on what self wants & just go4it muttering about freedom."
I guess you could do the same as you cruise down the road behind the wheel downing your Heinys or shooting ground squirrels fron a vehicle and think, because of our freedoms as Americans, that such acts should be allowed as well. Afterall, firearms and driving under the influence have never hurt anyone, right?
"I hope (hope springs eternal...) that any Natl. Council will be comprosed of more rational individuals than has been seen thus far here."
I agree. Hopefully you will not have anything to do with representing the herp community as a whole. Again, you let your bias and beliefs lead you to think you know more about herps and what is right than others.
"Hint guys: There is no logical analogy nor metaphor that connects traffic/guns/drugs/dogs etc. to the logical outcome of a taipan cruising the neighborhoods of our cities."
Another JG assertion. Might as well start crying that the sky is falling. I challenge you to find me one verified case where a person was invenomated and required hospitalization after being bitten by an eascaped hot. You're right, guns, drugs, dogs don't make a good analogy to a taipan cruising down the street. The others are likely to happen, do happen frequently, and have severe reprecussions. Can you honestly and FACTUALLY state the same is true about escaped hots?
"I've maintained lots of hots & more than once been distracted away from an open cage to come back & have to find & catch the nasty...Do it enough, it'll happen to you."
Now we know the basis for your concerns. You are applying the neglect you demonstarted while keeping venomous animals to others. Just because YOU didn't follow the rules of common sense when dealing with your animals doesn't mean th the right to keep such animals should be taken away from responsible individuals. And, I doubt it will happen to me or most venomous keepers because when we are working with our snakes there is only one concern when that cage is open...THE SNAKE! You do not turn away or let a distraction take you from an open cage. If something arises, you CLOSE the cage and deal with it. Irresponsible keepers like you is what we need to worry about. You give responsible keepers a bad name. And, why should keeping venomous be any different that doing anything else that poses a threat to other humans? We don't outlaw driving when people run red lights and kill others, or guns when a child finds their parents' fully loaded and unsecured firearm and shoot themselves. Why should hots be different? Because you say so and consider it an unnecassary risk? Let us then do away with everything that is unnecessarily risky and have the world become very boring and bland.
"When your hand is as scarred as mine, we can talk about what might constitute appropriate ammends for an unfortunate innocent."
Was this unfortunate incident do to your actions or someone else's? If your scarring is a result of how your kept or handled your animals, you have already done the best thing you could in getting rid of your venomous. And if that is the case, no ammends need to be made, except to you by you.
"Contrary to current thought...It aint "all about me"!
Did I miss something? It sure does seem to be "all about" you. It is what you think is wise, safe, and "logical." Your opinion is as valid as those of others, but until hot keepers, and herp keepers in general, prove they cannot responsibly keep herps, the outlawing of such animals should not occur. The greatest risk is always to the keeper, and it seems you have already learned that painful lesson.
Posted by G Watkins on July 27, 2001 at 19:42:10:
In Reply to: We see your error as well posted by Marty on July 27, 2001 at 12:18:55:
Hopefully you will not have anything to do with representing the herp community as a whole.
Marty, you aren't going to convince him by insulting him. And I for one would welcome his participation in these groups, all viewpoints need to be expressed, debated, and (with any luck) at least compromised on.
Besides, some of his points make excellent sense. I doubt that you can question that there are some people out there keeping venomous that have as much business keeping them as I have flying a Harrier.
Regalringneck:
You say:
"Hint guys: There is no logical analogy nor metaphor that connects traffic/guns/drugs/dogs etc. to the logical outcome of a taipan cruising the neighborhoods of our cities."
No, there isn't. In part, at least, because a Taipan loose in the city probably isn't going to be seen by anyone, much less bite anyone. I'm aware that pythons have worked into Florida neighborhoods, but it's important to note: they also evidently survived for quite a while and grew quite a bit without anyone knowing they were around, in spite of their size. A Taipan loose in the city is going to avoiding people, not attacking them; its also going to be severly disoriented and will likely spend most of its time hiding.
I mentioned in an earlier post the forest cobra I recaptured in an urban apartment building. It took the better part of three days to find the snake; in that time no one had seen it (most of the residents didn't know about its presence or escape, but considering average forest cobra behavior we would have heard about it if someone had come across it). What was it doing when I found it?
Hiding.
"I've maintained lots of hots & more than once been distracted away from an open cage to come back & have to find & catch the nasty...Do it enough, it'll happen to you."
Here I have to agree with Marty in a way. How could you become "distracted" when a hot snake's cage is open? It'd take a house fire and more to distract me under such circumstances...
And no, that never has happened to me, in spite of 40 years of experience with hot snakes.
"When your hand is as scarred as mine, we can talk about what might constitute appropriate ammends for an unfortunate innocent."
My hands are not scarred. I have never been hit by a hot snake, in spite of years that I handled and milked them (for a research project) on a daily basis. Many of my herp friends accuse me of being overcautious with them. I take it as a compliment, they have been bitten and I have not.
But by implication you are correct in one matter: if one keeps venomous snakes, one should damn well be responsible for them. They should not escape, there should not be a regular litany of "accidents," if there is something is wrong.
Once many years ago a nice family, parents and an 8-year old boy, came to view my snake collection. The nice boy, however, turned out to be rather bratty. After viewing the snakes and being allowed to handle a tame boa, he announced that I was a fake, that what I had said was an Eastern Diamondback was, as he put it, a "big garten snake you glued rattles on." He then announced that he was going to prove it, and to do so he started to open the diamondback's cage.
This was a 7 foot male diamondback that had been raised from birth in captivity in my home. He was very used to being around people. It was also not far from feeding time. The cage was on a level with the boy's face, and the diamondback was ready. If he had opened the cage, it would have struck him in the vicinity of his eyes - and, since it would be a feeding stroke and not defensive, major venom injection could have been expected. The kid has just watched me open an identical cage to take out the tame boa, so he knew how the cage opened. A worse scenario is hard to imagine. Or perhaps the worst was that the child's mother merely giggled and said something inane, like, "Now Johnny, don't do that" - while the kid is trying to lift the glass cage front.
But there was no crisis, no need for alarm. The cage, of course, was locked, and the glass was 1/4 plate, not easily broken. I was able to assure the brat that the snake was indeed a diamondback while ushering the nice family out of my home as quickly as possible.
My point is, if the kid had yanked open an unlocked cage, or broken flimsy glass, and had gotten bitten in the face - I would have been responsible. Not the monumentally-stupid kid.
If you keep venomous - or large boids - you have a duty to ensure that there are not "accidents." It can be done. It takes a little extra effort, but it's worth it.
Especially in terms of public relations.
Posted by regalringneck on July 28, 2001 at 00:58:59:
In Reply to: Marty, Regalringneck posted by G Watkins on July 27, 2001 at 19:42:10:
Hi G. W. N-joy your posts. I would have saved the forum this further tedium had you hotlinked your domain...
From several private-emails, apparently the expression & my subsequent use of "its all about me" is poorly understood (as I so oft am!). It was first observed by yours truly on a bumpersticker on a beautiful BMW convertible operated by a flashy young lady cruising past me on the san diego freeways @ 80 mph . I think it speaks volumes about many today. This value system clearly underlies many of the respondents to this tiresome thread.
Heres my thoughts regarding reasonable solutions then I'll append a couple more @ your inserted points.
I do feel a permit system would be reasonable for hots (mebbe
> a mentor program for a class 3 license as is being done w/ falconers) cuz
> hots must be kept under lock & key to be reasonably safe. Big constrictors &
> monitors I have less to no issue w/ cuz the risk is so much less. Ive heard
> the dart frogs become harmless in captivity???
>
> A permitting system would seem to allow serious hobbyists their freedom &
> limit access to hots by the many many nutcases running amok.
> Its degrees of dangerousness society must manage, & I think my ebola example
> distills the principal at the exstreme end. In the cities we just cant have
> anyone keeping really dangerous mobile organisms be they
> tigers/ebolas/chimpanzees or cobras. Can you imagine the damage awards that
> would be demanded of the city if a permitted animal escaped? How can that
> risk be in the interests of the general taxpayer who has no interest in the
> matter but will be asked to foot the bill?
> Perhaps keepers need to post a damage bond or buy an insurance policy.
> Theres people out there that would like to possess an armed cobra gunship,
> sometimes the answer just has to be no.
> N-joyed this latest xchange w/ you,
> john gunn
G. Watkins:
: "Hint guys: There is no logical analogy nor metaphor that connects traffic/guns/drugs/dogs etc. to the logical outcome of a taipan cruising the neighborhoods of our cities."
: No, there isn't. In part, at least, because a Taipan loose in the city probably isn't going to be seen by anyone, much less bite anyone. I'm aware that pythons have worked into Florida neighborhoods, but it's important to note: they also evidently survived for quite a while and grew quite a bit without anyone knowing they were around, in spite of their size. A Taipan loose in the city is going to avoiding people, not attacking them; its also going to be severly disoriented and will likely spend most of its time hiding.
: I mentioned in an earlier post the forest cobra I recaptured in an urban apartment building. It took the better part of three days to find the snake; in that time no one had seen it (most of the residents didn't know about its presence or escape, but considering average forest cobra behavior we would have heard about it if someone had come across it). What was it doing when I found it?: Hiding.
R squared: The fact that it was hiding is irrelevant to the real risk of it being discovered crossing the street or curled up behing the trash can & being assumed to be someones milk/corn/gophersnake & freehandled. Herpers responding to urban snake calls should always keep this possibility in mind.
: "I've maintained lots of hots & more than once been distracted away from an open cage to come back & have to find & catch the nasty...Do it enough, it'll happen to you."
: Here I have to agree with Marty in a way. How could you become "distracted" when a hot snake's cage is open? It'd take a house fire and more to distract me under such circumstances...
: And no, that never has happened to me, in spite of 40 years of experience with hot snakes.
R squared: Good for you, & shame on me. Trust me tho...it is really easy to do, here in phx. numerous children are being buried because their caregivers got distracted for just a few minutes (drownings). Humans are fallable, even those of us generally banging on all cylinders!
: "When your hand is as scarred as mine, we can talk about what might constitute appropriate ammends for an unfortunate innocent."
: My hands are not scarred. I have never been hit by a hot snake, in spite of years that I handled and milked them (for a research project) on a daily basis. Many of my herp friends accuse me of being overcautious with them. I take it as a compliment, they have been bitten and I have not.
R squared: Glad to hear it. Mine was a legitimate bite; digging an iguana out of a hole! My point was I know firsthand the agony these bites can cause.
: But by implication you are correct in one matter: if one keeps venomous snakes, one should damn well be responsible for them. They should not escape, there should not be a regular litany of "accidents," if there is something is wrong.
: Once many years ago a nice family, parents and an 8-year old boy, came to view my snake collection. The nice boy, however, turned out to be rather bratty. After viewing the snakes and being allowed to handle a tame boa, he announced that I was a fake, that what I had said was an Eastern Diamondback was, as he put it, a "big garten snake you glued rattles on." He then announced that he was going to prove it, and to do so he started to open the diamondback's cage.
: This was a 7 foot male diamondback that had been raised from birth in captivity in my home. He was very used to being around people. It was also not far from feeding time. The cage was on a level with the boy's face, and the diamondback was ready. If he had opened the cage, it would have struck him in the vicinity of his eyes - and, since it would be a feeding stroke and not defensive, major venom injection could have been expected. The kid has just watched me open an identical cage to take out the tame boa, so he knew how the cage opened. A worse scenario is hard to imagine. Or perhaps the worst was that the child's mother merely giggled and said something inane, like, "Now Johnny, don't do that" - while the kid is trying to lift the glass cage front.
: But there was no crisis, no need for alarm. The cage, of course, was locked, and the glass was 1/4 plate, not easily broken. I was able to assure the brat that the snake was indeed a diamondback while ushering the nice family out of my home as quickly as possible.
: My point is, if the kid had yanked open an unlocked cage, or broken flimsy glass, and had gotten bitten in the face - I would have been responsible. Not the monumentally-stupid kid.
: If you keep venomous - or large boids - you have a duty to ensure that there are not "accidents." It can be done. It takes a little extra effort, but it's worth it.
: Especially in terms of public relations.
R x R: that is exactly the point how do we (society) responsibly insure this "adherance to duty" w/o govt intervention???
I suggest a key factor for many of us to consider is why should we run the real risk of losing our hobby w/ critters as dangerous as a budgie, in order to provide a small solidarity for an even smaller minority that are infatuated with deadly herps? We need to be realistic & realize decision makers are not going to lose alot of sleep on this one. The path of easiest enforcement will be chosen if we dont start w/ a reasonable agenda. So we come full circle to my initial challenge & Im still awaiting that logic...but im not holding my breath!
cheers, jg
13-Foot Cobra Found In Orlando Home
Man Shoots, Kills Giant Snake
Posted: 11:29 p.m. EDT October 6, 2001
Updated: 12:24 a.m. EDT October 7, 2001
ORLANDO -- An Orlando man discovered a 13-foot deadly cobra in his home Saturday while he was walking in his garage.
Giant Cobra Found In Home
Rick Eslinger said that when he recognized that the snake was a cobra he took a picture and called police.
"At first I didn't want to mess with him because I thought he was just a native snake," Eslinger said. "I couldn't see what he was but when I saw that he was a cobra, we knew it had to end."
Eslinger shot and killed the snake. He told WKMG Local 6 News that he plans to have the cobra stuffed.
Officials say that there is no word on how the snake got into Eslinger's garage or where it came from.
Watch WKMG News for more details on this story.
Copyright 2001 by myCFnow.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed
:
: : I have in print and have for awhile the biggest onslaught on us as reptile keepers/breeders in this country of proposals, restrictions, and out right bans. Even if some of these don't pass they are on the books and can eventaully be looked at again and or up for consideration at a later date ! Remember that even small laws that were only in the "thinking" stage are now coming back up . I posted a city law up for banning animals in Colorado. How many think that this ban will only be kept in that city limit without going before the state of Colorado one of these days ? Ask New York how the whole proposed law came in that state ! I remember that some of these restrictions were only city wise ...now possibly state wide. JOIN UP ! Make this everyones stand that has ANY interest of EVER keeping reptiles and or keeping reptiles at this time. WE NEED TO BECOME VERY PRO-ACTIVE AND BE HEARD THAT WE AS A COMMUNITY/GROUP ARE NOT GOING TO STAND FOR THESE LAWS !
: : M Chambers
: : : Some of you may be tired of this from me but it is my feeling that with the surge of new and unfair herp laws in the past couple years we need the NRAAC . If we do not act now many of you will not be able to keep the animals you have . Hot herps and large boids will be the first to go . If things keep going the way they are we will be lucky to be able to keep a house gecko . We must act!! We must revive the NRAAC !!!
: : : Kevin Lorentz ---- NRAAC Ohio Chapter
: : : P.S. Dont believe the need ? take a look at the Law Forum.
: : : The rattlesnake was the favorite animal emblem of the Americans even before the Revolution. In 1754 Benjamin Franklin's Pennsylvania Gazette printed the picture of a snake as a commentary on the Albany Congress. To remind the delegates of the danger of disunity, the serpent was shown cut to pieces. Each segment is marked with the name of a colony, and the motto "Join or Die" .
: : : By 1774 the segments of the snake had grown together, and the motto had been changed to read: "United Now Alive and Free Firm on this Basis Liberty Shall Stand and Thus Supported Ever Bless Our Land Till Time Becomes Eternity"
: : : Many authors felt the rattlesnake was a good example of America's virtues. They argued that it is unique to America; individually its rattles produce no sound, but united they can be heard by all; and while it does not attack unless provoked, it is deadly to step upon one.
: : :
: : : Its time for that rattle to be heard again.
: : : Herpetoculture and Herpetology are under attack in the United States. hobbyists are going to prison, and spending massive amounts of time and money in court battles while super-collectors suck our ponds and lakes dry of turtles for the asian food market. Raids on hobbyists look like assualts on crack houses. Inane state laws are being utilized to entrap hobbyists into commiting federal offenses. The battles are being fought in the press with little regard to the actual outcome of the trials. Shipping regulations are being proposed that will literally shut this hobby down.
: : : Its got to stop.
: : : We've got to rattle.
: : : Its time to stand up and do something.
: : : Today I am proposing a new organization, The National Reptile & Amphibian Advisory Council. When the NHA went defunct we lost our voice. We can't wait around for PIJAC (Pet Industry Joint Advisory Council)to do something.
: : : NRAAC's charter will be to be a watchdog over federal and state agencies involved in the Reptile and Amphibian hobby/industry. In this role it will act as an advisory group to individual state member groups to provide them legal, financial, and media support. This organization is brand new and we will be looking for people interested in starting state chapters, and working at a statewide level.
: : : Please stop by this site (NRAAC site ) often and for the hobbys sake pass on this sites URL. Whether you are a hobbyist, academic, breeder, or 12 year old kid we need your support, financially and spiritually.
: : :
: : : Jeff Barringer
: : : Acting President
: : : National Reptile & Amphibian Advisory Council
: : : nraac@kingsnake.com
: : : -------------------------------------------------
: : : Listen to him we need not roll over and die or crawl under a rock .
: : : Kevin
