This thread was started in part out of my belief that the hobby needs to do much more in policing itself. I hoped to show a dangerous irresponsible activity and the negative feedback to it in order to educate “newbies”. Unfortunately (though understandably) most responses were simply too emotional, misdirected and lacking in the needed academics. I also failed to provide information on the status of the situation in my initial post.
An example: This is a very irresponsible activity. While an actual bite does not always occur this or any other venomous snake is very capable of inflicting a serious wound. Almost all venomous snake bites are associated with attempts to handle or harm the snake. Experienced keepers using safe techniques have even been bitten. A neonate Sidewinder may be one of the less threatening of N American Pit Vipers in terms of mortality but it still has the potential to inflict a painful bite associated with traumatic swelling, sickness, tissue damage, and other stress and damage to the body. Permanent damage is also a potential. It would not be an unusual event for this snake, held in this manner, to inflict a bite. The risk and severity of a bite completely precludes any possible reason to hold a venomous snake, especially in an unrestrained manner.
I agree that activities such as this have a damaging effect to the herp community in general. Poaching (illegal collection, selling and other such activities) is also a significant problem. I do not believe this post will have any influence on legislation. Medical statistics on snake bites are readily accessible and much more convincing as are other government statistics such as those from police and animal control agencies. I believe that the continued illumination of these activities within our community has a fare greater benefit than any negative feedback. We should not sweep these issues under the rug. I believe the primary reason laws are increasingly more restrictive is due to illegal collecting and commercial activity coupled with the failure of the reptile community to adequately police itself or lobby for its interests. One of the arguments for enacting strict legislation is the extreme difficulty in enforcing more liberal laws. One of the reasons laws make it to the books is the failure to adequately lobby against the need for them. How many legislators are amateur herpetologists? We need to stop misplacing the blame for our legal woes.
-----
Randy Hallman