I live in Indiana too. Could you describe it to me. I ended up with one a friend of a friend found (since I'm into these things) it turned out to be a blue spotted salamander. Not on the Indiana native list at DNR. If it's on the list you can't keep it. I'll give you the link, it took me a while to find.

http://www.in.gov/dnr/fishwild/endangered/regs.htm

Maybe this will help you narrow down your search too.
Good luck.
-----
**Kenn**