I agree, the Pets4U sounds a bit shady. I wouldn't purchase from them either if I didn't get a response.
Did you see the Coralife light on the other site (link posted below). I forgot to include it on the first reply back, but it was the global aquaria link. It says they're based in FL.
I guess you do what you have to do until you can get your replacement. Just make sure your little cutie is safe from taking a swim.
Coralife Light
-----
Phishie
Site Coordinator
"An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure."


