I gave it another go last night. I trimmed off the shreded leaves and still had about 6 good leaves left. I replanted the sword plant and he has finally decided to leave it alone. The other good news is that he hasn't touched the other two plants either. Hopefully this is the end of the plant shenanigans and I can feed him some fruits and other greens to feed his addiction.

Turtle 2, Jordan .5 maybe?