Reptile & Amphibian Forums

Welcome to kingsnake.com's message board system. Here you may share and discuss information with others about your favorite reptile and amphibian related topics such as care and feeding, caging requirements, permits and licenses, and more. Launched in 1997, the kingsnake.com message board system is one of the oldest and largest systems on the internet.

https://www.crepnw.com/
Click for 65% off Shipping with Reptiles 2 You

Diet and rescue and The Gregg syndrome

FR Jan 02, 2012 11:21 AM

The Gregg syndrome.

For Gregg, its not about being smarter then for phd product maker, or about making some product to promote. Its simply about monitors.

The problem is, those folks do not have successful experience with varanids, and this is a very specialized area of reptile keeping and the last frontier of reptile keeping. You know, where breeding is rare.

The problems with varanids is, not that they are complicated and specialized, its very much the opposite. They are simple and behavioral. And so extremely tuff.

For instance, us longtime successful varanid keepers know that varanids will feed well into death. So we do not use the old other snake gauges like it eats it, as a measure of success. Monitors eat anything and everything.

I just rescued a monitor that was lost in a cage for over a year, with no food or water. It drank and fed within hours of putting it in a decent cage, And is fine.

We had one lost in shipment for over six months, then it arrived where it was sent. Its was fine, six months in a snake bag in a small shipping box. And was fine.

Of course these animals lost a lot of weight, but for monitors kept in decent conditions, that is recovered within a day or two.

Now the problem, all species of varanids are prone to organ damage, with some species more then others. With wet land species being more prone to kidney damage then desert or drier habitat species. Liver damage is also a problem. And from various causes.

Whats odd about this is, these monitors can and do feed for about a month, then perish for failed organs. A common statement here is, well it ate yesterday!

What I have a some problem with, and the thread below is in that area is, RESCUE. from what I ask?

Then you talk about a RESCUE diet, like those canned foods. Cool, but still the question remains, what are you rescuing it from? Or what is it recovering from?

An example would be if there was kidney problems, feeding is not a good approach, electrolytes are. Etc.

Again as I indicated above, recovering from lack of food takes no special approach, not with varanids. Organ damage does take a special approach.

As long as their bare minimum is available for their use.

Yes, I can and do get confused, specially when the word rescue is envolved. Again, I think, rescued from what and heading to what. In most cases, its from the pot to the pan. I know, bad attitude I have. But I also got that bad attitude from this reality.

And for those that rationalize that breeding is takes something extra, well if you kept you cat or dog or mouse or horse, in conditions that would not support reproduction, you would be cited or arrested.

Reproduction is normal, and the design of all living animals. Its not the exception, its the bare minimum. Below the ability to reproduce is FAILURE.

With Varanids This reproductive failure is the norm. But that does not make it right.

ALso, as far as vets having a decent understanding of varanids, well that have not proved out either, With only one or two exceptions.

Allow me to get my bum in trouble one more time. That nice person, Wayne I believe, that is walking his Sav on a leash. Everyone that has posted that type of keeping as lost their wonderful pet within a year or two. AGain, they died, and died healthy. That is, died fat and normal looking. I really hope this does not occur with Waynes monitor, but I also hoped it did not occur with others kept that way. The problem is, 39" and over 10 pds, to much fat. My guess is, thats about 5 pds of fat.

The problem seems to be, monitors need to use that fat, in captivity, if they hold fat for long periods, then seem to perish.

Such monitors as Savs, have very long dry seasons where they use that stored fat on a yearly basis. Its not to be stored the lifetime of that animal.

In nature, they consume as much as they can, to store as much fat as they can hopely to get thru the next year. In captivty, the store never closes and they feed on a schedule yearly. There is much more to this.

For folks like Gregg, who comes here with a really nice Sav, and quotes all manner of stuff, I will remind you. This forum is about the keeping and breeding of Varanids. The actual keeping and breeding, not the theoretical keeping and breeding.

So if your going to take a foot hold on someones degrees or Uni they went to, try calling them and asking what their specific experience with VARANIDS is. You see, thats been the problem. generic information, has totally failed with varanids. What has succeeded is direct working experience. You know, actual success and failure experience.

Good luck and have a great new year folks. later

Replies (21)

dekaybrown Jan 02, 2012 11:40 AM

Thanks for that great post Frank..

One thing that makes my outdoor excursions different than most, it's not a city park you see there, it is my own private property that has been in my family 3 generations.

So my lizard is not going to ingest any pesticides, fertilizers or other chemicals used in artificially created landscapes.

Virtually all of the outdoor pics I have seen floating around on the web, are people walking their monitors in city parks (gasp) looking for attention. "See my cool lizard"

I on the other hand Loath attention, I have neighbours who would rather worry about me than themselves, so we usually drive out back and let him out of the truck to AVOID attention.

Couldn't help but notice I got exactly zero replies to my housing.. I am extremely proud of that enclosure, but I guess since no fault can be found in it, it's not worthy of any replies??
-----
Regards,
Wayne A. Harvey
Thamnophis US
Thamnophis.co
Thamnophis dot net

too many darn snakes to list anymore...

varanusaurus Jan 02, 2012 01:11 PM

The vast majority of reptile "enthusiasts" are completely unable to take constructive criticisms objectively. Instead, they tend to take it like a child would, and fire back with utter nonsense. It's as if these types refuse to step out of this normative comfort zone of horrible reptile keeping, and when that reaction is couple with feelings of responsibility... lol Whoa. This sort of human behavior is actually very interesting to me, but because I am passionate about varanids, it just pisses me off to no end... And that is precisely the reason why I no longer comment on the torturous captive settings in which so many people keep their herps. If I had commented on every detestable YouTube vid exhibiting said conditions, I'd certainly have had a stroke by now.

Before you reply, I want you to know that I am NOT saying you are one of these people, nor am I trying to insult you. I'm just saying why I (and I'm sure many others) ignored your thread when I first saw it. And if you need to know, that enclosure is probably insufficient. I'm really sorry that you're extremely proud of it and all, but it is what it is. The first thing I noticed is that it can't even house the necessary depth of substrate, thus, right off the bat, it is a bad cage... I think maybe you should do some more research, but mostly think more about your lizard than you and your lizard's relationship.

This is more or less the thing; No one cares about your cage -- we only care about what your lizard is able to do with the cage.

dekaybrown Jan 02, 2012 01:32 PM

The whole idea behind 30 inches of aluminum plating inside is to support the (supposedly optimal) 24 inches of dirt??

So who do I listen to?

I had started a 12 foot by 10 foot room in my basement and was told it was better to go with 8 feet by 4 feet and it would be impossible to sustain the correct environmental parameters in such a vast room.

again, conflicting information.

Do I look up, do I look down, or is it left or right.
-----
Regards,
Wayne A. Harvey
Thamnophis US
Thamnophis.co
Thamnophis dot net

too many darn snakes to list anymore...

murrindindi Jan 02, 2012 01:47 PM

Having a deep substrate helps with humidity, allows the monitor/s to dig/burrow, and is crucially important to give females somewhere to (hopefully) nest.
As you have a male, the latter obviously isn`t likely to happen.

FR Jan 02, 2012 03:38 PM

I think we are now missing the very most important part of deep substrate.

That is to live in, All monitors live inside something, burrows, crevices, hollows. They either make or pick spots that fit their bodies exactly. And They pick the right humidity. To not gain moisture or lose it.

These holes, etc are their homes. All wild monitors have these. Its here in these areas they spend the vast majority of their time.

And yes, for The owner of that Sav. Huge cages can be very very hard to control the right conditions.

Its not impossible, but very very hard.

About who to listen too. Thats easy, pick someone who has repeatedly done or is doing what you want to do. How simple is that.

The problem on the internet is, everyone is an expert. So yes, its difficult to know. So ask for support, you know, provide material that allows you to have faith in their words.

As it is, everybody is an expert and I do not blame you for your confusion. Good luck

varanusaurus Jan 02, 2012 02:15 PM

I don't see how that holds 24" of dirt, but you're telling me it does. Okay.

You should know that there is no mathematical equation for success with monitors. X amount of dirt does not get you X amount of lizard happiness. The idea that exactly 24" of substrate is optimal is laughable. If you did the research, and understood why they need deep substrate, what they use it for, you could figure it out on your own. There is no black-and-white solution.

The best thing that you could do is get it as deep as you can reasonably provide. That way, he can chill half-buried at the surface, or he could go wayyy down and literally chill out as he sees fit.

dekaybrown Jan 02, 2012 04:43 PM

But that's OK.....

I did in fact say I was still adding to the damn dirt.

Just added another six buckets, No one bothered to read the part about the bees hibernating in the dirt, or how I have to sift every single frigging ounce of it to ensure the bees are gone.

Now factor in that a winter storm just blew in and I cannot access the clay vein as easily, the dirt moving process will be even slower.

it's as if some of you people get off on beating your chests like a pack of gorillas.

That is exactly why in the five years I have been successfully enjoying my monitor I have not been posting here.

I have in fact been a member of this forum the entire five years, the non stop bickering turned me off then, and it's getting on my nerves now.

Back when I got him, you all told me to read Bennett's book, so I did, and I followed his findings and the formula worked.

Now warp ahead a half decade, and we have "experts" who claim that MAN can decide whats best rather than nature, physiology, biology and evolution.

The sad sad fact still remains, the captive "hobby" is flooded with obese lethargic Savs who croak before their second birthday.

Mom and pop pet stores still continue to sell babies for $35 to any teenager with an allowance. They are treated as "cheap disposable pets" and it kills me inside.

If I had a quarter for every post I ever read on other forums about "my sav just died, and I don't know why" "he always ate his dog food and boiled eggs" I could go to the laundry and wash a truckload of clothes.

I do my homework, and I do it well, I pay attention and I absorb.

To those who understand, Thank you. Your kindness and knowledge are greatly appreciated.

The only "professor" grading my homework that matters is my Sav.
-----
Regards,
Wayne A. Harvey
Thamnophis US
Thamnophis.co
Thamnophis dot net

too many darn snakes to list anymore...

Paradon Jan 03, 2012 12:11 AM

You're monitor looks very healthy. I can tell by the bright colors and clear bright eyes... It doesn't seem like what Frank is trying to tell you. A stressed and sick monitor will not look like yours. I've seen some sick ones and they don't look as bright, outgoing and inquisitive...

FR Jan 03, 2012 07:11 AM

again you have no concept of what I am talking about.

I clearly stated many times, 10 1/2 pounds is heavy for a young monitor that size. It wont take much more to be obese and then perish from what has killed off hundreds of HEALTHY SAVS.

Then what should I expect from a person with Zero experience with monitors. Cheers

dekaybrown Jan 03, 2012 11:52 AM

Come on now, let's see if you have been paying attention.
-----
Regards,
Wayne A. Harvey
Thamnophis US
Thamnophis.co
Thamnophis dot net

too many darn snakes to list anymore...

FR Jan 02, 2012 04:52 PM

Your absolutely right, 2 feet is just a place to start. A good place to start.

Which means, if you plan for this, then you most likely will be able to accomadate the monitors needs.

What is more important is usable substrate and that is a tough one. Thanks and best wishes

murrindindi Jan 02, 2012 02:01 PM

Hi varanusaurus, can you give the "necessary depth of substrate" (not to suggest it isn`t very beneficial, because it certainly is), but baring in mind this particular animal won`t be depositing eggs any time soon?

FR Jan 02, 2012 02:28 PM

Sorry did not see your cage, and what does that have to do with it?

Also it doesn't matter if its your property or a park. Thats not the point.

Your walk pics were wonderful to look at, but again thats not the point.

First off, I am not picking on you or anyone that walks their monitors on leashes. My point is make from what we see here, not individual people.

I am sorry if it hurts your feelings, its not meant too. My comments are meant to help your monitor live a long life. Other then that, its none of my business what you do.

If you want to talk about why and what not, that would be great, but all this my cage and whatever is not going to get anyone anywhere.

I would rather talk about what productive long lived monitors in my care acted like. And thats all I can offer.

I will start it off with, have you ever checked your monitors pulse. If not, you may learn something. Good luck

dekaybrown Jan 02, 2012 05:09 PM

My feelings are not hurt..

You of all people should know that, Not even sure if you remember, but we exchanged several private conversations in the past, since it was about the only way I could get anything from you without the constant interference of others.

So in checking his pulse, what heart rate should I be looking for?

For the record, I have in fact listened to him with a stethoscope. and I have looked into his ears with a flashlight, and when he eats, I am impressed by the cavernous passage of a throat.. I almost bet he could get a baseball down that pipe of his.
-----
Regards,
Wayne A. Harvey
Thamnophis US
Thamnophis.co
Thamnophis dot net

too many darn snakes to list anymore...

FR Jan 02, 2012 06:17 PM

Hi Harvey, No I do not remember the pm's, I do not try to keep track of them, as you can imagine, I get hundreds upon hundreds. I am sorry.

Also heartrate is a method to understand their stress levels. M

Most people confuse a sav being calm and laid back as tame. When in fact, they are highly stressed. This stress is what becomes a huge problem for Leash monitors.

The reality is, a healthy normal monitor would not tolerate a leash. They simply are too active. Again that slow walk is a sign of stress.
This occurs with wild monitors, once caught, they act calm and stop stuggling. But their heartrate is very high. You can put them down and they slowly walk off. Its a defensive mechanism.

Speaking of defensive mechanisms. You have no need to explain anything to anyone. All those here are trying to help. But its very hard to help, when these mechanisms take over, and they do.

Most of us have heard the same things over and over. And much of what you are saying has been heard over and over. And to a sad ending, which is why we/us/I are trying to help.

Also, most of what we say, those of us with experience, is very general, as we do not have your animal in our hands. Even pictures do not tell an accurate story.

So if your interested in a point, then its your task to stay on point and keep guiding the thread back to whats important. Again, thats your task.

For me, the leash thing and the weight are questionable. Remember, I do not know anything, I am not there. I am only guessing. So keep us real Wayne. Thanks

dekaybrown Jan 02, 2012 07:10 PM

For the most part, I don't even hold the leash, it's simply there to prevent him from complete escape, or finding a woodchuck burrow.

Hell one day he got really pissed at me and didn't want to come back into the house, He drew blood on me after I did actually catch up to him.

Once he decided to hit "full throttle" it was a challenge to catch up.
-----
Regards,
Wayne A. Harvey
Thamnophis US
Thamnophis.co
Thamnophis dot net

too many darn snakes to list anymore...

FR Jan 02, 2012 07:15 PM

Its not about the one time it did this or that. Its about what it does every single day.

Also, what would it do with the woodchuck burrow. Answer that and you now know what deep substrate is for.

You see, you know it would run down that hole and not come up. The reason is, its safe in there and you and others like you are out there. Cheers

dekaybrown Jan 02, 2012 08:12 PM

I already knew all about the burrows, it's common knowledge.

I also know they close their eyes when stressed, even though so many people call it relaxed.

Seems like everyone is fixated on what they ASSUME I don't know.

Never once in any of my posts did I EVER indicate that he does not burrow, nor have I ever indicated , oh whatever....

Like I have said more than once. I do my homework.

Maybe I have not been saying much in the past, but I stop in and read every day.

My cage design was based on reading your exact words of warning to others over and over again when they proudly show off their flimsy 4x8 box with minimal 2x4 framing, and you chime in about wet cement.

So when I went about constructing my enclosure, I built it as solid as a tank, and sealed it like a submarine.

How many other people installed support columns under the cage to keep the floor from saggig? Gee maybe it's because I know that 2-2.5 feet of clay dirt will weigh in at a ton or more.

Tell me that anyone you know of has ever used sheet aluminum in the bottom, or took care to use heavy pressure treated lumber that was aged in a barn so that all hazardous vapors had already been released?? bet you can't.. I never seen one like it.

I have a brain, and I use it.

The inability to get "on the same page" is what is frustrating.

-----
Regards,
Wayne A. Harvey
Thamnophis US
Thamnophis.co
Thamnophis dot net

too many darn snakes to list anymore...

FR Jan 02, 2012 11:01 PM

The last post stated, I know nothing of what you do, or know, there is no need for that. Why are you worried about what anybody things you know or don't know.

Heres a huge lesson, I do not KNOW anything, what I do, is try things and fine tune what works, and eliminate what does not work. I keep doing that until it results in something benefitual.

That is, Benefitual for the animal.

All you doing now is defending yourself, instead of doing that, try showing what has worked and what is working.

That is if there is some concern. If you have not concern about your monitor, then there is no need for you to be worried about what any of us think.

The point is, you can do all the friggin homework in the world, but thats not going to do anything. What tells you something REAL is the results.

As I said, I have two concerns, first, 10 1/2 pounds if awful heavy for that sized animal. And two, a monitor that just walks around when outside. Now, I only saw what you posted, which are still shots. As I mention, a healthy monitor, in my experience would not allow that. From what you said, yours rebells a little, thats a good sign.

Lets say that now all we have is the 10 1/2 pounds. What say you about that?

FR Jan 02, 2012 11:17 PM

Lets see if we can take another approach. Ok, When you walk it outside, whats the temps?

I have the strangest feeling that you may not understand what normal temps are for these types of animals. To put it simply, really hot. If its not 90F or above, its not of any benefit to the animal.

To think about that, your running your animal is a middle gear, and I imagine, that eventually kills them. As that is how they get fat. Not enough heat to burn those calories. Which also means, not running at full speed. At full speed, I would imagine you could not catch it. Again, from someone who has chased a few monitors in his day.

These types of reptiles do not come out in the open unless they are at full operating temps. To not be at those temps is stressful. As they know they cannot run.

Anyway, the case is, every person who did what your doing in the past has lost their animal. Hence the warning. Not got away, but died. And died soon, within a year or two. Which is very premature for a medium sized varanid.

What I do not understand is, why do you keep going on and on about yourself. If I hated those folks who lost monitors, I would hate everyone including myself. So stop with that junk.

Paradon Jan 02, 2012 12:59 PM

I once rescue a emiciated baby Sav from a pet store... It was very skinny...all you could see were bones and skin. I came home and gave it water, but when I fed it two mouse pinkies, it regurgitate all the food. For a while it could only hold down one pinky at a time each day. AFter it has gained back some weight I started giving it fuzzies all it could eat. It recovered...I know because he bit me! Haha It didn't hurt because he was small, but I know he was back to normal. After I had him for a while I gave him to my friend who loves monitor to look after him.

Site Tools