I do think it is a male after I thought about something you said.

The one on the left laid the eggs so no doubt she is a female.

I have the one on the right for almost a year now. It has not laid one single clutch of eggs. You said before that females can get gravid and lay infertile eggs. So, if it is a female, by now, there should have some type of yellow eggs then right? Are infertile eggs yellow?

http://i149.photobucket.com/albums/s63/c407027m/Alligator Lizard/DSCN2293.jpg
Image
-----
I will be back!