RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word....

Posted by: dhl at Tue Apr 6 18:27:31 2004 [ Report Abuse ] [ Email Message ] [ Show All Posts by dhl ]

No, you do not understand systematics. Your comparisons of Maxson and Wilson's study with that of Moriarty and Cannatella's are flawed. They are not addressing the same question; the later study is only looking at a single clade within Maxson and Wilson's. For what Moriarty and Cannatella attempt to do (address relationships within Pseudacris), there outgroups are fine. They're not attempting to resolve relationships among all Hyla. And the polytomy in the MP tree does not contractict the topology of the ML tree.

[ Reply To This Message ] [ Subscribe to this Thread ] [ Hide Replies ]

Hyla ('Pseudacris') regilla - a potential can of taxonomic worms - CKing, Wed Mar 31 12:42:48 2004

RE: Hyla ('Pseudacris') regilla - a potential can of taxonomic worms - dhl, Wed Mar 31 19:00:43 2004

RE: Hyla ('Pseudacris') regilla - a potential can of taxonomic worms - CKing, Fri Apr 2 02:55:42 2004

Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - dhl, Fri Apr 2 10:16:49 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - CKing, Fri Apr 2 13:48:51 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - dhl, Sat Apr 3 01:17:22 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - CKing, Sat Apr 3 08:32:51 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - dhl, Sun Apr 4 03:41:23 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - CKing, Sun Apr 4 19:54:41 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - dhl, Tue Apr 6 01:38:13 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - CKing, Tue Apr 6 16:17:33 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - shawn lockhart, Tue Apr 6 16:46:22 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - CKing, Tue Apr 6 20:37:28 2004

so, why is she now doing mtDNA work herself? - troy h, Mon Apr 12 23:53:31 2004

RE: so, why is she now doing mtDNA work herself? - CKing, Tue Apr 13 02:41:13 2004

since I've proven him wrong elsewhere . . . - troy h, Tue Apr 13 06:59:06 2004

RE: Immunological data - CKing, Tue Apr 13 12:45:46 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - dhl, Tue Apr 6 18:27:31 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - CKing, Thu Apr 8 00:13:14 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - dhl, Thu Apr 8 00:54:36 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - CKing, Thu Apr 8 22:02:28 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - CKing, Sun Apr 11 14:04:38 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - dhl, Sun Apr 11 20:49:11 2004

RE: Sure, it probably isn't the final word.... - CKing, Sun Apr 11 21:45:53 2004

and I refute your claim that all alterna have silvery-gray irises - troy h, Mon Apr 12 23:48:52 2004

RE: and I refute your claim that all alterna have silvery-gray irises - CKing, Tue Apr 13 03:03:37 2004

my point was that YOU WERE WRONG - conclusively demonstrated! - troy h, Tue Apr 13 07:03:04 2004

RE: An exception that proves the rule. - CKing, Tue Apr 13 13:30:36 2004

you contradict yourself - but thanks for admitting your error! - troy h, Fri Apr 16 14:32:38 2004

RE: If you understand biology... - CKing, Sat Apr 17 14:35:58 2004

RE: Hyla ('Pseudacris') regilla - a potential can of taxonomic worms - paalexan, Fri Apr 9 16:21:30 2004

RE: Hyla ('Pseudacris') regilla - a potential can of taxonomic worms - dhl, Fri Apr 9 16:49:17 2004

Unfortunately, not everyone is capable of freeing himself from the Hennigian straightjacket - CKing, Fri Apr 9 20:41:20 2004

RE: Hyla ('Pseudacris') regilla - a potential can of taxonomic worms - paalexan, Fri Apr 9 22:04:52 2004

RE: Hyla ('Pseudacris') regilla - a potential can of taxonomic worms - CKing, Fri Apr 9 22:24:53 2004

RE: Hyla ('Pseudacris') regilla - a potential can of taxonomic worms - CKing, Sat Apr 10 17:31:18 2004

RE: Hyla ('Pseudacris') regilla - a potential can of taxonomic worms - CKing, Fri Apr 9 19:05:40 2004

Since when did the facts matter to you? - troy h, Mon Apr 12 23:36:54 2004

RE: Since when did the facts matter to you? - CKing, Tue Apr 13 18:50:55 2004

RE: This is not a desert? - CKing, Tue Apr 13 23:48:15 2004

>> Next topic: An alternative way to delimit Pseudacris - CKing, Sun Apr 11 20:23:03 2004
<< Previous topic: trimeresurus - moadog, Tue Mar 30 11:20:34 2004